If the game is on the line i would choose Jason Kidd over Nash who is a proven playoff choker. Jason Kidd can average triple double in playoff round and he should have won the MVP after he turn the Nets into a contender in 2001-02.
right now, nash is way better scorer and a bit better distributor than nash, and that offsets difference on the defensive end.
so right now i'd chose nash, but with prime kidd it would be a much tougher decision.
prime kidd wasn't mvp just because prime duncan was around...but i guess you could say that for lot of players
Look Steve Nash is great too. He's a Hall Of Famer because of his MVPs, and no one can take that away from him. He makes everyone around him better, but he hasn't ALWAYS been doing this. Jason Kidd has been making players around him better since his early playground days, since playing for California, he's always been doing what he does. Nash just started this like how long ago? Was he even this good with Dallas?