Will Seth Rogen go down as the greatest comedian actor ever?

[1987_Lakers]

I think so, the guy is only 31 and has been in the following movies...

- 40 Year Old Virgin
- Superbad
- Knocked up
- Pineapple Express
- Zack and Miri Make a Porno
- Funny People
- This is the End (Comedy of the year)

[HardwoodLegend]

He didn't necessarily carry those films or was the main reason they were great though. Simply being in a good movie doesn't automatically mean you're great.

And, isn't 50/50 the best film he's been in?

[1987_Lakers]

Originally Posted by HardwoodLegend

He didn't necessarily carry those films or was the main reason they were great though. Simply being in a good movie doesn't automatically mean you're great.

And, isn't 50/50 the best film he's been in?

50/50 was great, but I don't really consider it to be a comedy even though Rogan added alot of humor to the movie.

[LBJMVP]

danny mcbride would be if he got more big roles.

[L.Kizzle]

No.

But I like him though.

[RidonKs]

god no. freaks and geeks is pretty much the reason he's become a household name, he's just a decent comedian who runs with the right crowds. he's got no charisma whatsoever.

[Nanners]

this is either the greatest troll thread of all time, or the dumbest thread of all time (okay maybe not all time, but dumbest thread of this month).

anyway, we all know Ben Stiller has already locked up greatest comedian actor of all time. did you see night at the museum 3?

[L.Kizzle]

Originally Posted by Nanners

this is either the greatest troll thread of all time, or the dumbest thread of all time (okay maybe not all time, but dumbest thread of this month).

anyway, we all know Ben Stiller has already locked up greatest comedian actor of all time. did you see night at the museum 3?

Ben Stiller is cool, but he's no Shawn Wayans.

[SpecialQue]

I like the move where he yells.

[alenleomessi]

i like him, but he is pretty much one-dimensional

[DuMa]

eddie murphy

[chips93]

Originally Posted by RidonKs

god no. freaks and geeks is pretty much the reason he's become a household name, he's just a decent comedian who runs with the right crowds. he's got no charisma whatsoever.

didnt freaks and geeks run for only one season? hes been in some big movies,any that were much bigger than freaks and geeks.

[RidonKs]

Originally Posted by chips93

didnt freaks and geeks ru. for only one season? hes been in some big movies,any that were much bigger than freaks and geeks.

i meant hooking up with apatow, that's the relationship that really launched his career far as i can tell

[bagelred]

Originally Posted by 1987_Lakers

I think so, the guy is only 31 and has been in the following movies...

- 40 Year Old Virgin pretty good, Steve Carrell movie
- Superbad - very bad
- Knocked up - not bad
- Pineapple Express - didn't see it, don't care
- Zack and Miri Make a Porno - didn't see it, don't care
- Funny People - very good, Adam Sandler movie
- This is the End - will see it eventually

Greatest comedian actor ever? easy there....caught up in moment as usual. This list isn't that great....so....but I like him and his stuff generally.

[AirTupac]

Originally Posted by bagelred

Greatest comedian actor ever? easy there....caught up in moment as usual. This list isn't that great....so....but I like him and his stuff generally.

Pineapple Express was a damn good movie. You need to catch up.