who will win ROY this year? and DROY?

[Legend of Josh]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

I'd be pretty surprised if the Colts don't get in the playoffs...

It seems Indy is headed there (playoffs), but there's many 4-6 teams floating around. We've seen the Bungals show up multiple times this season, but the Bengals have shown signs of life, and I believe they'll fight for that final wild-card spot.

We know either Pittsburgh or Baltimore is getting one of the two, and while some of those 4-6 teams have been more impression than the 5-5 Bengals, I personally *hope* Cincy finishes strong and both wild-cards come out of the AFC North.

It's likely the Colts will be competitive enough to win that final spot though.

[Carbine]

Why are you guys so quick to put Pitt in the playoffs?

They play @ Cleveland next week, a game in which Charlie Batch will be starting.

Then @ Baltimore, again....Charlie Batch.

Maybe Roeth is back after that Baltimore game.....maybe not, but they still got SD, Dallas & the Bengals left on the schedule.

I'm not so quick to pencil them in with Batch playing quarteback.

[ROCSteady]

Y'all already know my opinion. Griffindor Magic Baby

Originally Posted by Jackass18

I don't think the Colts will make the playoffs. I'm not sure who will take the WC spots other than Pittsburgh though. I'd guess Cincy. ROY is up in the air. RGIII is almost due to start having some bad games.

Or he'll just continute to improve and further prove his excellence and shutting up for naysayers who bitched bout how much we gave up for a transcendental player. Stop sounding like a beaten, jaded pessimist Redskins fandom of old regime.

Doug Martin has been absolutely incredible worthy.

I'm a huge Andrew Luck fan and he has transitioned about as well as I envisioned. He's already starting a future HOf career off the right way.

However, RG has been so efficicent and been a single-handed problem unlike any other PLAYER thus far, let alone rookie. 3 INT all year. The only other QBs in the whole league with 4:1 TD: INT ratio are Rodgers, Brady and Josh Freeman

[Jackass18]

Originally Posted by ROCSteady

Or he'll just continute to improve and further prove his excellence and shutting up for naysayers who bitched bout how much we gave up for a transcendental player. Stop sounding like a beaten, jaded pessimist Redskins fandom of old regime.

It's not that. It's that rookie QBs tend to suck in their rookie year or at the very least have some bad games, which he hasn't yet. Plus, our OL isn't all that great. You think he can go through his rookie season without 1 bad game?

[KingBeasley08]

RG3 gotta be frontrunner right now..

[Carbine]

They were talking about greatest rookie season this morning on NFL AM, and these dudes were just talking foolishness, just worthy stuff.

They said it's about wins. Eric Davis said he's take Joe Flacco as a rookie over RG3 because his team made the playoffs.

Then said he would take Matt Ryan' rookie season for the same reasons.

Then said Dan Marino made the superbowl in his rookie year.

Here is the video.

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-am/0ap...ie-of-all-time

[KingBeasley08]

damn those people stupid. happy that they don't vote for this award

[-p.tiddy-]

unfortunately I think alot of the people that vote do have that mind set...both with ROY and MVP...it's just as much of a team award as it is an individual award, maybe even MORE of a team award.


RG3 is having one of the greatest rookie years for a QB I have ever seen, he is playing at an ELITE level...but the team's W/L will be viewed against him even though it shouldn't

[KingBeasley08]

sadly I think you're right. skins gotta win out from here to really clinch it

[ClutchOver9000]

I'm a Giants fan and I think it would be a crime if RG3 doesnt win it.

Only way he doesnt get it is the Skins lose the rest of the way/he stinks it up the rest of the way.

Sure Luck is also a contender, the Colts are technically in playoff contention but what RG3 is doing is nothing short of spectacular.

[Jackass18]

Originally Posted by Carbine

They were talking about greatest rookie season this morning on NFL AM, and these dudes were just talking foolishness, just worthy stuff.

They said it's about wins. Eric Davis said he's take Joe Flacco as a rookie over RG3 because his team made the playoffs.

Then said he would take Matt Ryan' rookie season for the same reasons.

Then said Dan Marino made the superbowl in his rookie year.

Here is the video.

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-am/0ap...ie-of-all-time

Wow, that was pretty bad. The **** he bring Jeff George up for?

[ROCSteady]

Originally Posted by Jackass18

It's not that. It's that rookie QBs tend to suck in their rookie year or at the very least have some bad games, which he hasn't yet. Plus, our OL isn't all that great. You think he can go through his rookie season without 1 bad game?

Well not saying he wasn't gunna have a bad game but let's just say I KNEW he would play excellent against division rivals PHI n DAL and get us a WIN cuz he's already a true Redskin thru and thru and we deserve it.


It's easy to say that now but I have no reason to lie. I figured he would continue to improve all season and reel off a couple winning streaks, which is the case right now. HAIL

[Jackass18]

Well, hopefully he does it to the Giants, too, or our playoff hopes are all but gone.

[Nanners]

I think its still too early to tell. RG III, Luck and D Martin are all playing amazing, and they are all playing on questionable teams within reach of a playoff berth.

Right now I would put RG III in front, but that could change down the stretch considering all 3 of the above have shown the capacity to play absolutely spectacular football this season. Anything can happen on a given day in the nfl, guess thats why they play the games.

[-p.tiddy-]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

for DROY I like Janoris Jenkins, but it looks like Casey Hayward has the lead on that right now

Janoris with 2 pick 6s today

That should give him the lead

Rams found an amazing CB