who will win ROY this year? and DROY?

[-p.tiddy-]

looks like a three man race between Luck, RG3, and Martin

RG3's numbers are head and shoulders above Luck's but when it comes to QBs the voters might only see W/L's...if the Colts make the playoffs that could turn those real stats invisible

and then Martin has a chance to maybe become NFL rushing leader...if he can pass Peterson and the Bucs make the playoffs that could push him over the edge for ROY

my guess?...RGs will win and should win, what he is doing is amazing for a rookie QB


for DROY I like Janoris Jenkins, but it looks like Casey Hayward has the lead on that right now

[KingBeasley08]

some player on the pats named jones has been beast so far. Can't remember his name right now but he should be in the top 3 for DROY candidates. I doubt RG3 will win cause of record

[-p.tiddy-]

RG3 has a 100.0+ passer rating...Luck's is a 77.2

RG3 has 12 TDs and 3 INTs...Luck has 12 TDs also, but 12 INTs as well

from a statistical standpoint, it isn't even close really...




it is a real shame that W/L is viewed as QB stat by voters...

[jazz873]

Casey Haywards stats up until this week i believe:

29 targets 13 recs 45% completion 166 yards 0TDS 4INTS 23.7 nfl rating

Against the Lions he had 3 pass deflections 1 interception and a 0 nfl rating

[Carbine]

RG3 deserves the award based on individual play, but the way voters vote....they would give it to a guy on pace for 5000 total yards on a playoff team.

[Jackass18]

I don't think the Colts will make the playoffs. I'm not sure who will take the WC spots other than Pittsburgh though. I'd guess Cincy. ROY is up in the air. RGIII is almost due to start having some bad games.

[TheNaturalWR]

ROY: RG3. Luck isn't going to make the playoffs and I honestly wouldn't be shocked to see them lose out the rest of the season besides probably a win against Kansas City.

DROY: Chandler Jones

[Carbine]

We're virtually two games up on Cincy for the last playoff spot and 3 games up on everyone else.....Cincy still has to play at Pitt, Baltimore, at Chargers, Cowboys, at Philly....

We get to play Buffalo, Tennessee, Chiefs and likely a second unit of the Texans in week 17.

I expect to be in the playoffs.

[code green]

Trent Richardson deserves some love.

[Bano114]

Originally Posted by KingBeasley08

some player on the pats named jones has been beast so far. Can't remember his name right now but he should be in the top 3 for DROY candidates. I doubt RG3 will win cause of record

Chandler Jones. He's the brother of UFC Champion Jon Jones and the other Jones that plays for the Falcons. Not Julio. I think his name is Chris Jones?

[Carbine]

Originally Posted by code green

Trent Richardson deserves some love.

Not when it comes to who should be ROY.

[QUIZZLE]

I don't think Doug Martin has any chance at this point. I think it's a clear race between RG3 and Luck with Griffin a little bit slightly ahead at this point.

[QUIZZLE]

Originally Posted by code green

Trent Richardson deserves some love.

Maybe a consistently healthy Trent Richardson on a team where they had more than himself as a weapon.

[-p.tiddy-]

I'd be pretty surprised if the Colts don't get in the playoffs...

[Legend of Josh]

If the Colts win more than 7 games this season and Luck surpasses Bradford's most wins by # 1 overall selected QB, I think it'll be a landslide decision.

The way the season started, things seemed as if RGIII would easily coast to ROY, but as we seen Luck and the Colts surge the 'Skins and RG slumped.

Regardless of who wins the ROY, I think RGIII in the end will finish his career as the better QB compared to AL.