#71 NBA Player Of All-Time According to InsideHoops

[fsvr54]

Joe Dumars

[WillC]

Bob Lanier

[nycelt84]

Joe Dumars

[Duncan21formvp]

Penny Hardaway

[Heilige]

Joe Dumars

[pauk]

Alex English

(dont ask, i am at a random voting stage right now between 10 players lol)

[L.Kizzle]

Originally Posted by pauk

Alex English

(dont ask, i am at a random voting stage right now between 10 players lol)

Who are the other 9 players?

[JellyBean]

Earl "The Pearl" Monroe

[Deuce Bigalow]

English and Dumars each tied for the lead with 3 votes

[Dragonyeuw]

Just so that I understand the logic being applied here, how is it that Tmac has already gotten in, but I haven't seen one vote for Vince? Mcgrady's peak was higher(2003) but Vince had some solid seasons between 2000 and 2009( before he went to Orlando). Just seems to me that wherever one is voted, the other shouldnt be too far behind. The same work ethic issues apply to both,and Vince has had the more successful career between the two.

[MasterDurant24]

David Thompson

[haji_d_robertas]

Bump let's keep this going c'mon people.

[pauk]

Originally Posted by L.Kizzle

Who are the other 9 players?

Bill Sharman
Adrian Dantley
Joe Dumars
Alonzo Mourning
Earl Monroe
Sidney Moncrief
Dave Bing
David Thompson
Bob Lanier

[HardwoodLegend]

Originally Posted by Dragonyeuw

Just so that I understand the logic being applied here, how is it that Tmac has already gotten in, but I haven't seen one vote for Vince? Mcgrady's peak was higher(2003) but Vince had some solid seasons between 2000 and 2009( before he went to Orlando). Just seems to me that wherever one is voted, the other shouldnt be too far behind. The same work ethic issues apply to both,and Vince has had the more successful career between the two.

I think sometimes the good ole fashioned eyeball test is used.

T-Mac was simply a better and more dynamic player. Career success is partially rooted in luck. Vince has never made an All-NBA 1st Team (T-Mac did twice), and T-Mac has never flat-out disappeared on his team in the playoffs the way Vince has on a couple of occasions.

[1987_Lakers]

Joe Dumars