Is Dirk really a top 20 player?

[Kiddlovesnets]

Of all-time? No way, hes barely a bottom-line top 50 all time, and thats still largely due to the magnificent performance in 2011 playoffs.

[Smook A.]

Of all-time? No way, hes barely a bottom-line top 50 all time, and thats still largely due to the magnificent performance in 2011 playoffs.

[AlphaWolf24]

His team has the 2nd best win percentage of the last 10 years moron...LOL...loses this much

Regular season.....

Post season holds far more weight then the 82 game warm ups

[SCdac]

I got him top-25 ish in terms of all time impact and talent.

"Top 12" according to Carlisle, but I think that's just teammate love

[ThePhantomCreep]

Top 25.

You could make a case for top 20. Diminishing him for his gag job today is pretty silly. Does Duncan catch heat for going scoreless in the 4th quarter and OT of game 6 of the '13 Finals?

[Rocketswin2013]

Possibly not

[DirkNowitzki07]

Looks like we have a lot of fakkits that barely bagan watching basketball this year

Probably the same dudes that have Rose and Griffin ahead of Stockton and Duncan

Just cuz they can dunk so good

[westsideozzie]

He's great, but my top 20 players of all time need to affect the game on both ends of the court.

[nathanjizzle]

just a guestimate, but i would put dirk somewhere between 25-35. i wonder why people overrate him so much. maybe they are fascinated with his step back fadeaway which is a move players rarely use anymore.

[DMAVS41]

Regular season.....

Post season holds far more weight then the 82 game warm ups

That is regular season and playoff combined brah...

[Cone]

Regular season.....

Post season holds far more weight then the 82 game warm ups

id love to see kobes career without multiple HoFers.

most overrated player by far!

[STATUTORY]

id love to see kobes career without multiple HoFers.

most overrated player by far!

shaq is multiple?

[bballnoob1192]

id love to see kobes career without multiple HoFers.

most overrated player by far!

yea he won 2chips fmvps and one mvp and 3 trips to the finals........

[Cone]

dont kid yourselves... w/o shaq and gasol carrying his ass then he is another AI

[Rooster]

just a guestimate, but i would put dirk somewhere between 25-35. i wonder why people overrate him so much. maybe they are fascinated with his step back fadeaway which is a move players rarely use anymore.

I think you can make an argument about him being a top 20 but him making the the mediocre franchise like Dallas Mavericks relevant over the decade and his longevity will settle his case.