James Harden or Carmelo Anthony: Who Would You Rather Have?

[SilkkTheShocker]

Im personally going with Harden

[Budadiiii]

Westbrook

[Segatti]

Harden.

[Skywalker]

Harden of course.

[niko]

Harden's only a worse shooter, worse defensively and plays an easier to fill position. Clearly Harden because he's a Rocket.

[millwad]

Harden's only a worse shooter, worse defensively and plays an easier to fill position. Clearly Harden because he's a Rocket.

Different positions, ypu're comparing forward compared to a guard.
And Harden is a much better playmaker.

[KingLeBronJames]

James Harden is not all that great. I'd take Melo.

[TexasBloodMoney]

James Harden just drives into the paint and throws his arms up hoping for a foul. He usually gets the calls but if he isn't, he's pretty awful.... and he's a bitch that flops.

I'll take Melo.

[SilkkTheShocker]

Different positions, ypu're comparing forward compared to a guard.
And Harden is a much better playmaker.

Definitely. It isn't even really close either.

[kuniva_dAMiGhTy]

Harden's only a worse shooter, worse defensively and plays an easier to fill position. Clearly Harden because he's a Rocket.

And Harden is better at getting to the line, finishing around the rim, and playmaking for his teammates.

[Donnybrook]

Carmelo without a doubt. Harden shows more inconsistency and cannot close out games like we've seen Melo do.

Maybe Harden will surpass Melo as far as consistency and ability, but right now it's all Melo. I mean, we're talking about one guy who isn't in the MVP talks and one guy who arguably is. You tell me why.

[2LeTTeRS]

I'd take Melo still. He's simply a better pure scorer and closer than Harden.

[STATUTORY]

Carmelo without a doubt. Harden shows more inconsistency and cannot close out games like we've seen Melo do.

Maybe Harden will surpass Melo as far as consistency and ability, but right now it's all Melo. I mean, we're talking about one guy who isn't in the MVP talks and one guy who arguably is. You tell me why.

media? hype? east coast bias?

cause it ain't basketball reasons

[SilkkTheShocker]

Carmelo without a doubt. Harden shows more inconsistency and cannot close out games like we've seen Melo do.

Maybe Harden will surpass Melo as far as consistency and ability, but right now it's all Melo. I mean, we're talking about one guy who isn't in the MVP talks and one guy who arguably is. You tell me why.

Harden name is starting to float around the MVP talks. Not top 5 by any means, but he is getting some love. Melo's MVP consideration is dropping faster than a girl's panties on prom night.

[SilkkTheShocker]

I'd take Melo still. He's simply a better pure scorer and closer than Harden.

Closer is such a stupid, stupid way to rate players.