OJ Mayo Or Derrick Rose Who You Got?

[lilojmayo]

im very very very deeply sadden and surprised i havent seen this out of all the dumb player or player threads some that dont even make sense

OK who would you rather have OJ Mayo or Derrick Rose

im not going into their numbers because its obvious Mayo is better at scoring/shooting catergories pts FT% 3pt% a lil better in rebounding, better on defense

while Rose is better at FG% and assists. so their no need to break down their stats.

heres them just to look at.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/players/4387 Derrick Rose
http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/players/4389 OJ Mayo

ive asked this question on many other forums and the responses have been quiet surprise in fact startling

especially to

Kobe Fans
Ive had many many kobe fans indirectly say that Lebron and Wade are better than Kobe basically incrimininating there kobe love.

Kobe Fan: Well lilojmayo Derrick Rose is better he does more than just score he rebounds passes his assists are so much better than OJ's so is his T/O and his dunks are crazy he is so explosive he just does more.

lilojmayo: You know if i put Dwyane Wade or Lebron instead of Rose and Put Kobe instead of OJ you basically just said that they were better than Kobe

Kobe Fan: Well since Mayo is a sg he job should be put the ball in the hoop just like Kobe does, so ill take Mayo on this one.


so who you got and why?
OJ or Rose this thread could easily be renamed
Kobe or (Bron or Wade)


and yeah i got Mayo because he do work


ISH Vote Count

Mayo- 11

Rose- 22

[miles berg]

Derrick Rose. I dont see the need to give reasoning.

[SoCalMike]

i could have sworn there was a thread like this a few days ago.....

[artificial]

Rose because he do work


[COLOR="White"]idiot[/COLOR]

[Meticode]

At this point I'll take Rose over Mayo.

Both players are playing very well, but I'm always more fond of of PGs who can run the floor, distribute the ball well, while having the ability to drive to the basket over scorers.

[The Nets]

Rose because he's a younger player and has much more potential...

[RoseCity07]

Rose, but it's close.

Mayo was my second pick in the draft.

1.Rose
2.Mayo
3.Beasley
4.Gordon

[tsforthrees]

Rose. just saw highlights of the sixers/bulls game. wouldn't want to be andre miller right now...

[ChiBulls7]

Rose, obviously.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REPO797Fs8Y

[baseketball4life]

these two are great players, future superstars... id take mayo

[Ken_Masters]

Rose. No question.

[Lebron23]

Derrick Rose. Kid just destroyed Andre Miller. OJ Mayo will be a future NBA All Star, and the best scorer in the 2008 NBA Draft Class.

[KenneBell]

Mr. Mayo. Rose is great but OJ is smooth as glass.

[TmacsRockets]

Rose.

Rose vs Mayo is like Lebron vs Melo.

[BFRESH44]

Still would take B'Easy over both on my squad...Pooh Rose is special ball player too, though. Knew that from the jump...