Duncan > LeBron on the ATG List

[warriorfan]

5 Rings

0 Collusions

Better defender

Does not stifle the offense with ball domination

Better leadership and intangibles


Tim Duncan stayed with his original team for 20 years and brought 5 rings to them

San Antonio, just like Cleveland had zero titles before Tim

The only difference between Tim and LeBron is that Duncan never had to abandon his City and brought them their 5 first rings

LeBron had to collude twice to bring one (that was tainted by the tampering of the commissioner of the nba as well)

[SexSymbol]

easily.
Not even the most hardcore bran stans would argue otherwise.

[Nilocon165]

easily.
Not even the most hardcore bran stans would argue otherwise.

lol

[NBAGOAT]

Duncan was drafted into a decent situation with Drob so get out of here with the collusion stuff. Stifling or not, Lebron's a better offensive player no matter how you spin it. Personally, I take Lebron over Duncan but wouldn't argue too much with someone who takes Duncan.

[ShawkFactory]

Perhaps but Lebron is only 31 so we'll see.

[stalkerforlife]

easily.
Not even the most hardcore bran stans would argue otherwise.

Duncan's easily better, but Bransvestites are trolls and would argue with a wall.

Bran is a flopping troll. Bransvestites are trolls. Just a troll generation.

Nothing is real for them.

[SilkkTheShocker]

LeBron has more MVPs, and was the man on the same amount of title teams. Giving the edge to LeBron here. Especially since his 16 Finals win absolutely s.hits on anything TD in his career. Sidenote: Both are much better than Kobe.

[Mr Feeny]

They're both top 10 players

Kobrick is 12th and can only weep having retired on a lower tier compared to these 2 legends

[ArbitraryWater]

even Duncan fans like TLP wont argue Duncan over LeBron anymore..

[CavsLebronMo]

Duncan only won because of the commissioner giving the Spurs the first pick. The entire NBA is rigged. Bruce Bowen was an alien, asterisk on all wins.

They only wanted the Spurs to win so people would visit San Antonio. Rigged. Always rigged. Everyone was injured when the Spurs won. Every team. LeBron had a broken back in 2007. He would have won in 3 games if he was healthy. Rigged and Fixed.

[SilkkTheShocker]

Duncan was drafted into a decent situation with Drob so get out of here with the collusion stuff. Stifling or not, Lebron's a better offensive player no matter how you spin it. Personally, I take Lebron over Duncan but wouldn't argue too much with someone who takes Duncan.

People like to skim over this part. LeBron was drafted to the eastern conference's version of the Clippers. The Spurs had a fluke season where D-Rob got hurt, and they got to benefit from getting the #1 pick. LeBron spent his first 7 seasons playing with two different terrible front offices. And 7 years of Silas, and later Brown as his head coaches.

[bigkingsfan]

Lebron caused the most meltdowns ever, so he wins by default.

[SilkkTheShocker]

Spurs have also beaten some tomato cans in the Finals. Knicks, Nets, and the Cavs? All three of those teams wouldn't be mistaken for talented. The Knicks had a bunch of injuries, and the 07 Cavs are definitely the least talented team to ever make it. Their #2 was a rookie PG that was drafted in 2nd round. Every team LeBron beat in the Finals was more talented than any team TD beat in the Finals.

[stalkerforlife]

Lebron caused the most meltdowns ever, so he wins by default.

Wrong.

Bran never caused a single meltdown, other than the meltdowns by his fans as he cowardly ran away from teams when times got tough.

The NBA caused the meltdowns for those opposing the manufactured star that Bran is.

Duncan simply laughed on the bench and had a technical called on him; THAT is a meltdown.

[bigkingsfan]

Wrong.

Bran never caused a single meltdown, other than the meltdowns by his fans as he cowardly ran away from teams when times got tough.

The NBA caused the meltdowns for those opposing the manufactured star than Bran is.

Duncan simply laughed on the bench and had a technical called on him; THAT is a meltdown.

You ran away from the boards for a month after game 7, definition of a MELTDOWN.