-
Possessed by B-Ball
If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
I think he would be the first one to not make it. Not enough cumulative stats or achievements besides a single MVP.
What say you?
Last edited by Ancient Legend; 02-19-2015 at 04:17 PM.
-
... on a leash
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
We're talking about the trades right now, stfu
-
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
-
n/a
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Is Marcus Camby a hall of famer? yea, thought so
-
Dunking on everybody in the park
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
ehhh probably on the border, but as time passes his legend will increase exponentially... like penny and hill
so maybe because he has the MVP, but my guess right now would be no
this thread is just asking the rose haters to complain about his mvp, return, injury problems and syntax
-
ISH's Negro Historian
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Yes.
MVP. All-NBA 1st Team. Three Time All-Star. Conference Finals. In Five Seasons.
There are players with more seasons and less accolades in the Hall. The late Walt Bellamy played 14 seasons, with only one more All-Star appearance. No MVP or All-League Teams or Conference Finals. He's In.
-
Dunking on everybody in the park
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Originally Posted by L.Kizzle
Yes.
MVP. All-NBA 1st Team. Three Time All-Star. Conference Finals. In Five Seasons.
There are players with more seasons and less accolades in the Hall. The late Walt Bellamy played 14 seasons, with only one more All-Star appearance. No MVP or All-League Teams or Conference Finals. He's In.
Rookie of the year and 2 fiba gold medals too
I think he gets in if stays even at this level for the rest of his career
but right now it would be a polarizing subject, i mean mitch richmond got in so it isnt inconceivable
would be awesome though
-
#Trump4Treason
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Why would roses career end, its just beginning.
-
ISH's Negro Historian
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Originally Posted by The_Pharcyde
Rookie of the year and 2 fiba gold medals too
I think he gets in if stays even at this level for the rest of his career
but right now it would be a polarizing subject, i mean mitch richmond got in so it isnt inconceivable
would be awesome though
Calvin Murphy. 1 All-Star game. Finals Appearance.
Earl Monroe. 4 All-Star games. 1 All-NBA 1st Team. No MVP. A ring though.
If Kevin Johnson gets in this year ...
-
Possessed by B-Ball
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Originally Posted by L.Kizzle
Calvin Murphy. 1 All-Star game. Finals Appearance.
Earl Monroe. 4 All-Star games. 1 All-NBA 1st Team. No MVP. A ring though.
If Kevin Johnson gets in this year ...
KJ made deep playoff runs, and maybe his helping to keep the Kings in Sacramento nudges him in, but as a player he's borderline.
Rose has flamed out in the playoffs, and looks like his best years are behind him in terms of athleticism and scoring ability.
-
Curry fam
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
The basketball hall of fame isnt that prestigious. I say the mvp is enough
-
National High School Star
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
No. But if he plays 4-5 more seasons of above average ball and they make several ecf or finals appearances...then sure
-
Dunking on everybody in the park
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
No way.
Rose's only elite seasons were 2011 & 2012. He was good in 2010 but he wasn't a top 10 or 15 player.
On his resume he has an mvp, 3 all stars, and an all nba 1st team along with weak career totals in stats.
He wouldn't be hall of fame if he retired today and he won't be unless he can be a top 10 player again for at least a few seasons.
-
2nd Greatest Player
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Originally Posted by Ancient Legend
KJ made deep playoff runs, and maybe his helping to keep the Kings in Sacramento nudges him in, but as a player he's borderline.
Rose has flamed out in the playoffs, and looks like his best years are behind him in terms of athleticism and scoring ability.
KJ is underrated. Prime KJ in today's NBA = Best Point Guard in the league.
-
Dunking on everybody in the park
Re: If Derrick Rose's career ended today, would he be a HOFer? (All former MVPs are in)
Originally Posted by nathanjizzle
Why would roses career end, its just beginning.
This is laughably false.
Rose is 26 and missed 2 seasons that were vital to his development due to serious injuries. He is not what he used to be and once his athleticism fades away he will fall of severely.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|