Do you agree with this NBA Top 15 All-Time?

[Bladers]

To have Bird ahead of Kobe is comical. Comedy gold.

I have Kobe ahead of Bird and if Bird is ranked so high than Kobe is easily cracks the top 4.

Kobe is Tier 1.

Don't just make statements like that.
Tell us reasons why...

[jlauber]

Sorry i was away from the computer because i have a life, job, family and girlfriend.

Anyways, Your right. Kobe is not top ten of all time. He is top 17 according to bruce and Lebron is top 19. Now you happy?

Here is my list. Top 10 All-Time:

1. MJ
2. Wilt
3. Kareem
4. Russel
5. Magic
6. Hakeem
7. Bird
8. Kobe
9. Shaq
10. Duncan

Not quite in my order, but looks very good to me.

[Jacks3]

Tell me why not?

Duncan has..

More team success as #1 option
Similar peak
Greater longevity
More accolades/accomplishments
Was considerably better defensively.
Arguably better playoff performer


Shaq has...
A greater peak
Greater longevity
More accolades/accomplishments
More team success as the #1 option.
Better playoff performer

[SEEBASS1234]

Sorry i was away from the computer because i have a life, job, family and girlfriend.

[jlauber]

LOL at you thinking Duncan over Kobe is ridiculous. It can go both ways and can be argued both ways.

Needless to say, they were BOTH great.

[guy]

lol @ thinking that Kobe is over Shaq and Duncan.

The funny thing is if it weren't for Shaq, the argument for Kobe over Shaq would be even weaker.

[TheLogo]

My true list.....


1. Kareem

2. MJ

3. Magic

4. Wilt

5. Kobe

6. Bird

7. Russel

8. Duncan

9. Shaquille

10. Hakeem

[TheLogo]

The funny thing is if it weren't for Shaq, the argument for Kobe over Shaq would be even weaker.

Shaq had the luxury of playing with the best shooting guard ever, second or equal to Jordan.

How many players get to do that?

[Lebron23]

You are too sensitive.

Get out of your glass house.

Prime Larry Bird was a better playoffs performer than Kobe Bryant.

[TheLogo]

Prime Larry Bird was a better playoffs performer than Kobe Bryant.

If I am not mistaken Kobe has a better PER than Bird.

I hate to use PER too.

[OldSchoolBBall]

the best shooting guard ever, second or equal to Jordan.

What a fukcing tool this guy is.

[MasterDurant24]

Shaq had the luxury of playing with the best shooting guard ever, second or equal to Jordan.

How many players get to do that?

Kobe had the luxury of playing with possibly the most physically dominant player in history. And Kobe over Bird and Shaq, Magic over Wilt, Duncan over Shaq? Either championships are taken too much into account or just people are just idiotic.

[MasterDurant24]

If I am not mistaken Kobe has a better PER than Bird.

I hate to use PER too.

PER...got to be freakin kidding me...

[TheLogo]

Kobe had the luxury of playing with possibly the most physically dominant player in history.

Wilt Chamberlain says hi.

Kareem says hi.

Russel says hi.


Kobe played with one of the many great centers in histroy. Shaq played with the best SG in history, equal or second to MJ.

[guy]

Shaq had the luxury of playing with the best shooting guard ever, second or equal to Jordan.

How many players get to do that?

Just because he had the SECOND best sg ever, doesn't mean that was the only way he could've won. Prime Shaq was easily the easiest player to build around during that time, and one of the easiest of all-time. Shaq would've won titles eventually no matter what. Switch Kobe with T-Mac, Vince, AI, Pierce, Ray, and maybe some others, and they still win 2-3.