Dwyane Wade vs. Tracy McGrady at their peaks

[TheNaturalWR]

Wade - During that stretch;
37.2 ppg
5.9 rpg
10.4 apg
2.9 spg
1.4 bpg
.553 fg%
.419 3pt%
.865 ft%
41.85 eff

It will remain debatable when it comes to 2002-03 T-Mac vs. 2005-06 Kobe vs. 2008-09 Wade.

Best player by far during that season and better than T-Mac's peak as well. His worst game was 21 and 10? Are you kidding me?

[StateOfMind12]

Yea 35 year old shaq best player in the world How stupid can you be?

He was referring to LeBron as the best player in the world and Shaq as the most dominant Center in NBA history.

How far in the playoffs did Magic get after Kareem?
.

He made it to the Finals in 1991, horrendous analogy.

Wade has a finals MVP. McGrady has never seen the second round of the playoffs /thread

I give McGrady plenty of crap for not being able to get past the 1st round but Wade didn't get past the 1st round during his peak either at least when he was playing with a supporting cast similar to McGrady during his peak.

I think if we are comparing careers or even primes, the answer is quite easily Wade but it's different because we are simply comparing peaks.

As much as I hate McGrady, if you were to pair up McGrady from '01-'03 with Yao from '05-'07, they would have probably made it to the Finals and maybe even win it all. McGrady never got anywhere with Yao in the Rockets because he was just not that good anymore.

McGrady was just an underachiever in the Yao-Tmac experiment but if he did play the way he was expected to play which was the Tmac from '01-'03 then they probably would have been a dynasty or the next Kobe-Shaq together like many said and thought they would be, or at least win one title.

[Legends66NBA7]

How far in the playoffs did Magic get after Kareem?

Should of omitted this example.

Went 63-19 the very next season (got upset by the Suns in the second round) and his final year in his prime 58-24 and went to the Finals... and took Jordan/Pippen Bulls beating them... while many key players were injured.

Yeah, he didn't win a title, but he got far enough and came 3 wins away from winning a title.

If that whole AIDS thing didn't happen to him... who knows, might have gotten another chance at a title.

He made it to the Finals in 1991, horrendous analogy.

Yeah, don't know what he was thinking there.

[iDefend5]

@ you talking about someone else not knowing anything about basketball.

You forget to switch to your RRR3 account or something?

[Heavincent]

You forget to switch to your RRR3 account or something?

You're one to talk StateOfMind. Do you seriously think we don't know it's you?

You've got like a trillion accounts on here. Who the hell does that? Loser

[iDefend5]

You're one to talk StateOfMind. Do you seriously think we don't know it's you?

You've got like a trillion accounts on here. Who the hell does that? Loser

Go ask someone to check the IPs if you think I'm him. It will detect it for sure.

[schism206]

You base an entire season for 1 game? Really?

Isn't that what everyone is doing for Wade tonight? How many best SG threads just popped up