Prime Wade vs Prime T-Mac?

[CJ Mustard]

Give me Mac.

[plowking]

Wade better on offense and defense.

Wade.

[Gabuyaux]

Tmac.

[dhsilv]

Never really saw Tmac with anyone else who could play so it's hard to judge.

My gut says Tmac was a hair better due to his passing and defense, but I'll be honest Tmac games weren't exactly on tv much either during his peak.

[Prime_Shaq]

T-Mac was better offensively because of his range but I'll go with Wade as a two way player.

[GrapeApe]

I'll go with the guy who had a playoff run of 28/6/6/2.2/1.1 on 50% en route to a championship and FMVP.

[WayOfWade]

Is this actually a conversation? Whatever, I'll get to it tomorrow

[JohnFreeman]

Wade, and this really isn't a debate.

[3ball]

If Tmac had Wade's intensity and determination, it would be Tmac.

Tmac had more talent pound for pound... But Wade was a determined player who maximized his talent.

Tmac didn't get UP for games and leave it all on the floor like Wade would.

For example, I remember that one Christmas game with Wade against Kobe, where the media was really hyping the matchup - I knew Wade felt underappreciated compared to the media's fawning over Kobe and would take this opportunity to destroy him... (40 points, 10 assists later.....)

I never got that feeling in any big game or matchup game with Tmac, like "ok, I know Tmac is really hype for this - he's doing to destroy whoever".. I never got that feeling with Tmac, and he always seemed to underwhelm..

That being said, Tmac had a very good turnaround jumpshot on the post and some high level wrinkles in his offensive repertoire.. maybe a more diverse repertoire... It's hard to say, but I still go with Wade.. I trust him more to BRING it.

[SpaceJam]

Wade.

Also first 3ball post I have seen where he isn't mentioning MJ at ALL, what is the world coming to

[FKAri]

Duane Weighed

[Dr Hawk]

Wade in a heartbeat

[derb2k2]

DWADE DA GAWD, that's who!

[Angel Face]

Wade all day, pre-prime wade was an NBA champion! Prime T-Mac couldn't get out of first round?

[CJ Mustard]

Is this actually a conversation? Whatever, I'll get to it tomorrow

We're awaiting your response.