Better All-Star Team ?

[L.Kizzle]

1962 WEST ALL-STARS
F - Elgin Baylor
F - Bob Petit
C - Walt Bellamy
G - Oscar Robertson
G - Jerry West

1992 WEST ALL-STARS
F - Chris Mullin
F - Karl Malone
C - David Robinson
G - Magic Johnson
G - Clyde Drexler


Which is the better squad.

[HaNdLe ThE RoCk]

i'll take 1992

[basketballer4]

Same here.

[Glove_20]

Originally Posted by L.Kizzle

1962 WEST ALL-STARS
F - Elgin Baylor
F - Bob Petit
C - Walt Bellamy
G - Oscar Robertson
G - Jerry West

1992 WEST ALL-STARS
F - Chris Mullin
F - Karl Malone
C - David Robinson
G - Magic Johnson
G - Clyde Drexler


Which is the better squad.

Guards- Magic might have the edge over Robertson, but West's edge over Drexler is way too much...

Advantage: 1962 All-Stars


Fowards- Malone and Baylor is like a tie, but Petit >>> Mullin

Advantage: 1962 All-Stars



Center- I'll give this one to Robinson

Advantage: 1992 All-Stars





Overall: 1962 All-Stars

[shafir]

92 by far.

[wally_world]

92... Magic is like Top5 player of all-time... David Robinson is just so gonna crush that Walt dude... and Karl Malone is a Power-house... no fight...

[Brunch@Five]

The '92 team is perfectly put together.

Magic at PG, perfect distributor, GOAT PG.
Drexler is an extraordinary slasher, good defender and rebounder at the guard position.
Mullin is a bonafide scorer, one of the best shooters ever.
Malone is a good defender, great scorer from 18 feet and inside, great passer and rebounder.
DRob is one of the best defenders at the C position ever, a great rebounder, scorer and passer.

Also, Magic, Drexler and Malone would form an awesome fast-preak trio.

[ThaKid]

ill take 1992 cuz im 17

[MTing]

92'

[thabisyo]

'92 all day

[tmacattack33]

In 1960, the USA population was 180 million.

In 1990, it was 250 million.


In 1962, the league was not fully integrated yet. In 1958 (I don't have this stat for 1962, but it can't be too far off from 1962), the league was not fully integrated yet and the league consisted of about 10% african americans.

In 1992, the league was fully integrated and consisted of 70 +% african americans.


In 1960, I don't know of many very international players.

By 1990, the game was international and there were a few good international players in the nba.

















I'll take the 1992 all-star team without even looking at who was on the roster.

[Just2McFly]

62 easily. 92's back court is getting DESTROYED by big o and jerry west. You are talking about two of the sickest scorers in history