Quote Originally Posted by MMM
Ray Allen is an elite shooter but that didn't make him an elite basketball player.
Right on the money.

Just cause Rose does 1 or 2 things at an elite level that doesn't make him an elite player.

Melo a few years back was an elite scorer, did that make him an elite player? Nope.

Rose has come a long ways from his rookie year but he still has a far ways to go if he's gonna be considered an all-time great.