No one should have Bill Kareem Wilt on "Mount Rushmore"

[rlsmooth775]

No one here saw them play you don't even have full box scores of games they played

[JohnFreeman]

i never saw Hitler in real life, but I am fairly sure he was a bad guy

[redboy]

were you there to witness the presidency of Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, George Washington, or Thomas Jefferson?

[nzahir]

i never saw Hitler in real life, but I am fairly sure he was a bad guy

i actually laughed, but true

[rlsmooth775]

How can you rank players when you never saw any of their games. Just look at incomplete stats and imagine the impacts on wins

[MP.Trey]

were you there to witness the presidency of Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, George Washington, or Thomas Jefferson?

Aaaand.. /thread.

[CavaliersFTW]

shut up OP we'll do whatever the f*ck we want

[hahaitme]

were you there to witness the presidency of Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, George Washington, or Thomas Jefferson?

To be fair the actions of a US President are always going to be much more heavily documented than a sporting figure, much less a sporting figure from a period where the sport itself wasn't nearly as big as it is now.

Plus, a President will almost always leave a large impact on the whole country, you don't really have to have "witnessed" Abraham Lincoln's efforts in person because his actions changed shit for good. You already KNOW what he did.

It's hardly comparable to a box score or a few highlights. Just sayin

[CavaliersFTW]

To be fair the actions of a US President are always going to be much more heavily documented than a sporting figure, much less a sporting figure from a period where the sport itself wasn't nearly as big as it is now.

Plus, a President will almost always leave a large impact on the whole country, you don't really have to have "witnessed" Abraham Lincoln's efforts in person because his actions changed shit for good. You already KNOW what he did.

It's hardly comparable to a box score or a few highlights. Just sayin

We've got more footage of George Mikan than we do Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, George Washington, or Thomas Jefferson combined. So...

[ProfessorMurder]

i never saw Hitler in real life, but I am fairly sure he was a bad guy

First of all he lost the war, so they're empty stats.

Secondly, we don't even have the full box scores on what he did.

He could be good for all we know.

[fpliii]

No one here saw them play you don't even have full box scores of games they played

Sorry, no matter how much hand-waving you do, you can't categorically dismiss them.

[Milbuck]

Every time I see one of your threads, I think to myself "Give him a chance Milbuck. Maybe this time it won't be shitty". But time after time, you make me regret that thought.

Congratulations on being arguably the shittiest poster of your class.

[MichaelCorleone]

Kareem and Wilt I agree.

But 11 rings automatically puts you in top 4 no questions asked.

[CavaliersFTW]

First of all he lost the war, so they're empty stats.

Secondly, we don't even have the full box scores on what he did.

He could be good for all we know.

He's probably terrible, weak era for dictators TBH, dictators were smaller/weaker/less intelligent back then. Kim Jong Un would dominate/be GOAT of that era.

[no pun intended]

Kareem and Wilt I agree.

But 11 rings automatically puts you in top 4 no questions asked.

Good job. Keep up the good posts.