Jordan and Brady playing pickup basketball

[Ca$H]

Tom Brady has won more than Brady and Montana played with no salary cap on a LOADED squad year in year out. Brady had a lot less talent on his team in a much tougher era.

Brady > Montana

Brady is the GOAT and playoffs GOAT

Agreed. Brady is an alpha. It's weird that you an avatar of Bran though. How could you like Brady and Bran? Brady is more similar to MJ and Kobe. While Bran is similar to Peyton Manning.

[BasedTom]

Tom Brady has won more than Brady and Montana played with no salary cap on a LOADED squad year in year out. Brady had a lot less talent on his team in a much tougher era.

Brady > Montana

Brady is the GOAT and playoffs GOAT

tougher era? Are you 12?

Ryan Tannehill threw for 4000 yards this season- along with 10 other QBs. I like Tannehill, but if you can't see how 4k yards in 2014 is worth way less than 4k yards in previous eras...

[Ca$H]

Walsh and Montana both joined the 49ers the same year

Checkout Montana's stats on the Chiefs. Brady is old right now too. So that isn't an excuse.

[SouBeachTalents]

Checkout Montana's stats on the Chiefs. Brady is old right now too. So that isn't an excuse.

Check out Montana after Walsh left. 2 MVP's and another Super Bowl. I'm sure if Montana played in an era where the defense wasn't allowed to hit you or the receivers, he'd be putting up gaudy numbers too

[Ca$H]

Check out Montana after Walsh left. 2 MVP's and another Super Bowl. I'm sure if Montana played in an era where the defense wasn't allowed to hit you or the receivers, he'd be putting up gaudy numbers too

Same system bro. Kind of like Nash with Alvin Gentry. Not to mention Rice.

[ShawkFactory]

Same system bro. Kind of like Nash with Alvin Gentry. Not to mention Rice.

Brady never won a super bowl with Moss.

[Ca$H]

Brady never won a super bowl with Moss.

He only played one year with prime Moss. Plus he had an ankle injury in that Super Bowl.

[secund2nun]

Playoff average
Montana: 2 TD, 1 INT, 250 ypg, 95 rating
Brady: 2 TD, 1 INT, 253 ypg, 89 rating

Pretty amazing Brady only averaged 3 more ypg considering he attempted 5 more passes per game and plays in an era that has neutered defenses

Super Bowl numbers

Montana: 11 TD's, 0 INT, 286 ypg, 127 rating
Brady: 13 TD's, 4 INT, 268 ypg, 95 rating

That's right, Montana had a 100 quarterback rating in EVERY Super Bowl he played in, and NEVER threw a pick. Brady just threw two this past Super Bowl. Montana also never scored under 20 points in any Super Bowl, Brady's done it twice, both resulting in losses.

So sorry, Montana is the postseason king

Montana played on a loaded team with no salary cap. Also Montana had a bunch of one and dones. Brady has reached the Super Bowl 6 times vs just 4 for Montana despite Montana have a huge advantage of no salary cap.

[Beastmode88]

MJ still talking shit @ 50. That alpha male mentality.

[scandisk_]

chubby jordan

[SouBeachTalents]

It's close either way, I've got Montana and Brady as the top two QB's of all time. I just choose Montana because he put up great numbers for his era, and he was Jordan like in the Super Bowl. 100 QB rating every game, never threw a pick, scored at least 20 points every time. Brady just has never been as reliable, relying on his defense and Vinatieri for his first Super Bowl, scoring 14 and 17 points in losses against the Giants, and tossing two picks and needing a epic coaching gaffe to beat the Seahawks. Montana has 3 Super Bowl's better than any of Brady's

[dreamwarrior]

Montana's the greatest I've ever seen. Brady is a great QB, but I lost a lot of respect for him after deflategate.

[JtotheIzzo]

Who has won more than Brady?

Peyton may be the GOAT regular season player but Brady is GOAT of the postseason.

Peyton is the GOAT if you want circus stats indoors against sub-500 teams in October, but if you need a game winning drive in February, Brady is the GOAT.

Even the two Super Bowls they flukily lost, Brady drove them down field for go-ahead scores in the 4th.

Look at what he did against an all-time defense in the 4th quarter of this Super Bowl. Anyone who thinks he isn't GOAT is simply a hater.

[SouBeachTalents]

Peyton is the GOAT if you want circus stats indoors against sub-500 teams in October, but if you need a game winning drive in February, Brady is the GOAT.

Even the two Super Bowls they flukily lost, Brady drove them down field for go-ahead scores in the 4th.

Look at what he did against an all-time defense in the 4th quarter of this Super Bowl. Anyone who thinks he isn't GOAT is simply a hater.

First of all, that's false. The Pats didn't score a single point in the 4th quarter of the 2011 Super Bowl. And fluky or not, after averaging 30 ppg both seasons, including breaking the scoring record in '07, Brady and the Pats put up 14 and 17 points in their two defeats

[SaltyMeatballs]

"man you better pull up Michael Jordan (on YouTube)" - MJ

GOAT gon' GOAT