Penny or McGrady: If never injured, who is better all time

[ProfessorMurder]

I'd probably take Penny over TMac.

[tmacattack33]

?????

Peak Penny put up 21/4/7 with 2 stls on .605 TS%.

Peak Hill put up 21/9/7 with 2 stls on .556 TS% or 26/7/5 on .565 TS%

Not only this, but Grant Hill was one of the best perimeter defenders in the league.

Grant Hill was not a great defender back then. He actually only became a good defender some how in Phoenix a few years ago.

And I don't care about the stats. And even if I do, I don't understand what you are showing there...because those stats are pretty equal...one of them rebounds better (the one who was a small forward as opposed to a PG) and one of them shot more efficiently.

[SamuraiSWISH]

Give me Penny, at least he and Shaq went to the finals, and didn't he score 42 points against prime Pippen and Jordan?

Prime Jordan is 1990 - 1993. So no. And I believe you're confusing his lone back to back 40 point games against Riley's Heat. Defensive juggernauts who never had double 40s dropped on them. I really prefer Penny's combination of scoring, and distribution. He was a refined post player too coming out the gates. He had nice dimension to his game.

[greymatter]

Penny.

They were both similar scorers with Penny being more efficient, except Penny was better at carrying a team than Tmac.

[Hoopz2332]

McGrady...and it's not even close.

this