Nash, JK, GP. Who's the better PG? Player?

[Cali Syndicate]

I prefer Payton because he is more of the all around balanced player.

Nash is mainly for offense regards and while Kidd is great for an offense, he's never really been a scorer. Kidd's defensive premise is among the best at his position too though.

The thing I find amazing is the longevity of Nash and Kidd, Nash especially. Kidd has found a great role on the Mavs and has been playing it perfectly.

[Yung D-Will]

Honestly Nash/Payton/Kidd are so completly differnt that it's really hard to compare them. But they all up right after guys like Stockton and Isiah all time