Westbrook or Rose?

[Upgrayedd]

If you knew in 2008 what you know now. Who would you pick?

[keep-itreal]

If Derrick Rose was never injured, Derrick Rose

[JohnMax]

D-Rose

not because he's better but because he not a cancer.

[Cocaine80s]

Westbrook

[Upgrayedd]

If Derrick Rose was never injured, Derrick Rose

Of course. If Rose was still healthy, I'd take him easily over Westbrook. But I asked if you knew back in 2008 that Rose was going to be so fragile and have all these injuries, who would you take?

The only things Rose has going for him to me is that he's from Chicago and while he's out there he still shows flashes of how great he once was and hopefully can get back to that.

But with Rose out again due to ankle injuries, I start wondering how good this Bulls team would be with Westbrook or Rondo.

[SugarHill]

Westbrook, injuries or otherwise

[keep-itreal]

Of course. If Rose was still healthy, I'd take him easily over Westbrook. But I asked if you knew back in 2008 that Rose was going to be so fragile and have all these injuries, who would you take?

The only things Rose has going for him to me is that he's from Chicago and while he's out there he still shows flashes of how great he once was and hopefully can get back to that.

But with Rose out again due to ankle injuries, I start wondering how good this Bulls team would be with Westbrook or Rondo.

then of course I would take Russell Westbrook. Derrick Rose is done, I don't get people getting hyped over his SECOND return.

[JimmyMcAdocious]

You mean back in 2008 that Rose is injury prone or that he definitely ends up injured like he has? Grant Hill was injury prone until he no longer wasn't (tho he was never the same player). People thought Curry was injury prone early in his career and look at him now.

I take GOATbrook tho.

[dubeta]

Westbrook probably already played twice the amount of games as D Rose

[Upgrayedd]

You mean back in 2008 that Rose is injury prone or that he definitely ends up injured like he has? Grant Hill was injury prone until he no longer wasn't (tho he was never the same player). People thought Curry was injury prone early in his career and look at him now.

I take GOATbrook tho.

Not that he was injury prone but that he would tear his ACL, then his meniscus and miss almost 2 entire seasons.

[Genaro]

Westbrook, specially because of his defense. Though he had his fair part of injuries as well.

[nathanjizzle]

rose. westbrook still a nobody.