2005 Ginobli or 2014 Harden?

[sejoon101]

Discuss

[Smook A.]

Of course people are gonna say Manu because they hate Harden.

2005 Gino: 16 ppg/4 apg/4 rpg 47% fg in 30 mpg

2014 Harden: 25 ppg/6 apg/5 rpg on 46% fg in 38 mpg

[russwest0]

That one that plays both ends of the floor.

[Hamtaro CP3KDKG]

Manu by far got it done in the playoff Harden wont
The defensive gap is enormous too

[ABfor3]

Manu by far got it done in the playoff Harden wont
The defensive gap is enormous too

Yeah cuz Harden totally had the GOAT PF play beside him , not to mention one of the best coaches ever

[Wavves]

Harden is the better player, but who would I rather want on my team? That would have to be Ginobili

[sammichoffate]

This thread proves stats aren't everything

[Deuce Bigalow]

One was the FMVP and a champion tbh

[Yankstar]

The one that isn't team cancer

[DFish24]

The one who got robbed of Finals Mvp.

[Milbuck]

[sejoon101]

This thread proves stats aren't everything

Seeing the other thread about Spurs, it gave me the thread idea..

I figured the stat difference is huge, but wanted to see the input of ISHers.

Honestly I'm having a hard time choosing who I'd want on my team, it would be highly situational.

None of that considered, who I'd just rather have, I think I'd take 05 Manu over 14 Harden by a small margin, because of the defensive gap..

Honestly believe Manu is the far more intelligent player, and if he played more minutes and got the touches, would avg more ppg than 16, although I don't think he would avg as high as Harden nor do I think Manu's offensive arsenal is better than Harden's overall.

[russwest0]

The one who got robbed of Finals Mvp.

So James Harden? Felt like he was Miami's Finals MVP in 2012.

[Black Mamba's B]

So James Harden? Felt like he was Miami's Finals MVP in 2012.

[Combat Wombat]

Of course people are gonna say Manu because they hate Harden.

2005 Gino: 16 ppg/4 apg/4 rpg 47% fg in 30 mpg

2014 Harden: 25 ppg/6 apg/5 rpg on 46% fg in 38 mpg

I hate Harden and every hair in his stupid f#cking beard but I think he's better his 2014 season is far better.