-
Buck Dynasty
Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Where would you rank Kevin McHale in today's NBA ?
-
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
-
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Best white player. Maybe top 15 overall
-
... on a leash
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by christian1923
Best white player. Maybe top 15 overall
dumb as shit
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Other than bron, durant, davis, steph, paul, and Westbrook idk of any are hands down better.
-
NBA Superstar
-
Since 1974
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
He'd still be that talented pain in the ass. Hated him back then.
-
College star
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
His 1987 "version"? Only PF I'd take over him, nowadays, would be Anthony Davis, also because of potential/upside.
-> Peak McHale would've clearly been a top10 player right now, borderline top5 even...
Similar to what he "was" back then.
It lasted very little though, only major downside to it, pretty shameful...
He was really coming into his own by 1984, kept improving and they had to move him into the starting lineup in 1985, still took that extra step and really peaked in 1986-87... But then played through a broken foot for the 1987 Playoffs which really screwed him, never the same again, just kept going downhill from there into his 30's...
Describing him at his peak:
Dude was just a great scoring PF.
He had every move you can think of while in the post (only Hakeem rivals him at that), extremely close to unstoppable there 1on1, terrific soft-touch around the rim, had a hook-shot and a turnaround fader.
Had very good basketball IQ, moving without the ball going to his best spots, winning position.
Could hit plenty of open jumpers with some range to it, shot over 80% from the FT line.
Great overall defensive player, pretty good rebounder...
Not what you'd call a bad passer (in terms of skill) but certainly not that close to a good one and could turn into a blackhole plenty, many times tried to do too much if not "influenced" otherwise.
Was very tall, extremely long, pretty mobile but not very strong or physical.
Didn't have that pick-n-roll/pop game.
Despite being a great defender, didn't have that defensive bigmen anchor type of impact, ala Timmy or KG.
Didn't have that killer mentality either, nor that alpha-dog work ethic.
-
I don't get picked last at the park anymore
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
He wrote the book on up/ under & his version of the sky hook he was near unstoppable
With the ticky tack sh*t they call now, he might out do Harden on the line.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdtgUOiWHJg
Barkley on open court said he was the best he ever played against
and Charles was a beast.
easy top 5 today
-
College star
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by turret
He wrote the book on up/ under & his version of the sky hook he was near unstoppable
With the ticky tack sh*t they call now, he might out do Harden on the line.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdtgUOiWHJg
Barkley on open court said he was the best he ever played against
and Charles was a beast.
easy top 5 today
That vid always gets me, beautiful display of scoring in the post, just amazing
Don't know about best but he definitely said, plenty of times, that McHale was his toughest matchup (could even be on both ends combined).
Wouldn't say easy top5 today though, not at all...
Active players I'd take over 1987 McHale would be LeBron, Durant, Curry, Davis, probably Westbrook and CP3, you also got Harden... So, wouldn't really say top5 but very close to it anyways.
Like I've said, similar to what he "was" back then.
And, again, shame that it lasted very little.
-
NBA Legend
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by SHAQisGOAT
His 1987 "version"? Only PF I'd take over him, nowadays, would be Anthony Davis, also because of potential/upside.
-> Peak McHale would've clearly been a top10 player right now, borderline top5 even...
Similar to what he "was" back then.
It lasted very little though, only major downside to it, pretty shameful...
He was really coming into his own by 1984, kept improving and they had to move him into the starting lineup in 1985, still took that extra step and really peaked in 1986-87... But then played through a broken foot for the 1987 Playoffs which really screwed him, never the same again, just kept going downhill from there into his 30's...
Describing him at his peak:
Dude was just a great scoring PF.
He had every move you can think of while in the post (only Hakeem rivals him at that), extremely close to unstoppable there 1on1, terrific soft-touch around the rim, had a hook-shot and a turnaround fader.
Had very good basketball IQ, moving without the ball going to his best spots, winning position.
Could hit plenty of open jumpers with some range to it, shot over 80% from the FT line.
Great overall defensive player, pretty good rebounder...
Not what you'd call a bad passer (in terms of skill) but certainly not that close to a good one and could turn into a blackhole plenty, many times tried to do too much if not "influenced" otherwise.
Was very tall, extremely long, pretty mobile but not very strong or physical.
Didn't have that pick-n-roll/pop game.
Despite being a great defender, didn't have that defensive bigmen anchor type of impact, ala Timmy or KG.
Didn't have that killer mentality either, nor that alpha-dog work ethic.
And right now...I would take a peak McHale over AD. Long term, probably not.
-
NBA Superstar
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by LAZERUSS
And right now...I would take a peak McHale over AD. Long term, probably not.
Agreed
-
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by ArbitraryWater
dumb as shit
You probably never watched him play
-
College star
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
Originally Posted by LAZERUSS
And right now...I would take a peak McHale over AD. Long term, probably not.
Hmm, I don't know, you could definitely say that though...
Kevin was clearly a better scorer although AD has been a clear-cut #1 option while being a better rebounder and showing he can pass or share the ball better/more than McHale. Their defensive impact, as of right now, is pretty comparable.
McHale at his best was a proven winner though, a very smart, "refined" veteran with very good impact on some great teams...
Long term? Knowing what I know now? I'd definitely take AD (providing he keeps it up and stays healthy), as he's only 21 and prime McHale lasted very little...
-
NBA Legend
Re: Where Would You Rank Peak Kevin McHale Today?
He'd be worse defensively but better offensively in today's league.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|