Do People Believe Melo Is a Superstar?

[SilkkTheShocker]

Aside from homer Knicks fans of course. All he does is score and he doesn't play D or make anyone better.

[sbw19]

[COLOR=Teal]I don't, but it doesn't help his case that this Knicks team isn't built around him.
[/COLOR]

[Bob Cousy]

a superstar doesn't have to have those intangibles. It has more so to do with media and mass appeal than on court play.

[SilkkTheShocker]

[COLOR=Teal]I don't, but it doesn't help his case that this Knicks team isn't built around him.
[/COLOR]

Yea but even when teams did build around him they lost in the 1st round 7 times.

[Sarcastic]

Your dad does.

[SilkkTheShocker]

Your dad does.

My dad knows a lot about basketball than you do. But I guess thats nothing to be proud of.

[Figlo]

Overrated

[bmulls]

He was a superstar with the Nuggets, I think his stock has dropped a little since they gutted their team to get him and the Knicks were playing so bad.

[kennethgriffin]

melo is a great player. just doesnt belong in this system

he should be on a team where he can be a ball dominant player and isolate

this knicks team is built on a pg working with cutters and screan and rolls

hes a superstar who needs to be traded for a few more complimentary pieces like chandler/fields etc...

[SilkkTheShocker]

Overrated

[sbw19]

[COLOR=Gray]Yea but even when teams did build around him they lost in the 1st round 7 times.[/COLOR]

[COLOR=Teal]That's no reason not to consider him a superstar when he played for the Nuggets when TMac was called one for a good stretch in his career, KG too in Minny had his fair share of 1st round shortcomings.

It's too early to judge, give him a season or two, see what happens now that he has Amare and Lin.
[/COLOR]

[Sarcastic]

Yea but even when teams did build around him they lost in the 1st round 7 times.

If Lebron played in the Western Conference during those years, he would be first round fodder too.

The Nuggets were the underdog almost every year. Lebron lost with HCA throughout twice in his career already.

[Scholar]

I bet your dad told you post this thread after he had anal sex with you, OP. That's why you're such an anal person.

[SilkkTheShocker]

If Lebron played in the Western Conference during those years, he would be first round fodder too.

The Nuggets were the underdog almost every year. Lebron lost with HCA throughout twice in his career already.

And if you replaced Lebron with Melo, Cavs are 1st round fodder every season. Melo isn't a superstar. Get over it.

[Yanch856]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fztGWYgCinw

Don't know if you guys remember this Melo, like 2 yrs ago.

He was considered unstoppable at one stage. He looked incredible that year.

Now? He needs to lose weight and try harder. Seriously he's like a shell of his former self.

Wow I'm watching this and they're two different players right now.