How far apart are Kobe, Melo, Westbrook impact-wise?

[Akrazotile]

Assume all are in their prime.

[BrainDead]

Kobe
Westbrook









Melo

[IncarceratedBob]

Today?

Westbrook





Kobe

Melo

Peak?

Kobe













































Westbrook




































Melo

[ImKobe]

Kobe
Westbrook














































































[COLOR="White"]Melo[/COLOR]

[Heavincent]

Not sure why you put Melo there. It's like asking what QB is best between Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, and Matt Stafford. One of them clearly doesn't belong.

[Hittin_Shots]

Not sure why you put Melo there. It's like asking what QB is best between Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, and Matt Stafford. One of them clearly doesn't belong.

It's not like asking that at all cz I have no idea who two of those are and only know the other by name.

[Akrazotile]

Kobe
Westbrook














































































[COLOR="White"]Melo[/COLOR]

[Cold soul]

Peak play:

Bryant























Westbrook
































Melo

[SugarHill]

Kobe
Westbrook














































































[COLOR="White"]Melo[/COLOR]

[imdaman99]

Agree with everyone, Melo is the guy who clearly doesn't belong amongst the other 2.
Knicks are only stuck with him for another 5 years. Declining Melo

[SugarHill]

Agree with everyone, Melo is the guy who clearly doesn't belong amongst the other 2.
Knicks are only stuck with him for another 5 years. Declining Melo

I think it's a load of BS. Melo at his best is, at worst, on the same level if not better than Westbrook. I'm not buying this underrating of Melo. Shit is silly

[imdaman99]

I think it's a load of BS. Melo at his best is, at worst, on the same level if not better than Westbrook. I'm not buying this underrating of Melo. Shit is silly

I don't think Melo can wreck the other team the way Westbrook has shown he already can. Dominating on both sides. Melo can get hot and it is a lot of fun to watch because he is hitting shots from all over the court but those instances never come anymore. I am done with Melo

[navy]

Melo stays underrated.

[K Xerxes]

I think it's a load of BS. Melo at his best is, at worst, on the same level if not better than Westbrook. I'm not buying this underrating of Melo. Shit is silly

At his best, Westbrook can put up a 40+ point triple double with 4+ steals, maybe a couple of blocks and a lot of energy on the defensive end.

At his best, Melo can chuck his way to 50 points maybe with double digit rebounds, but more than 5 assists would be shocking. As would a solid job on defense.

[DetroitPistonFan]

Impact from Carmelo? What he hell has he done? All he does was have like 10 1st round exits.