#15 NBA Player Of All-Time According to InsideHoops

[DaHeezy]

When did "Julius" become better than Elgin Baylor?

Hodge? he's obviously never been better. Dr.J however has always been

[DirtySanchez]

What is Lebron doing there at 11?

I haven't been following this at all so I have no right to complain but that's not right

People are ranking their opinion that his peak out ranks others.
Really they are disrespecting just disrespecting the game and jumping the shark. Oh well it's inside hoops.

[ImmortalD24]

Kevin Garnett

[Vertical-24]

Julius "Dr. J" Erving.

[pauk]

What is Lebron doing there at 11?

I haven't been following this at all so I have no right to complain but that's not right

...............Lebron........Moses.........West... ....Oscar.....
MVP.............3................3...............0 ............1........
FMVP............1................1...............1 ............0.........
CHAMP..........1................1...............1. ...........1.........
ROTY...........Yes..............No.............No. ........Yes.......
All-NBA..........8................8..............10... ........9.........
All-Defensive...4...............1...............4..... .......0.........
All-Star..........8................12.............14.. ........12........
All-Star MVP....2................0...............1......... ..3.........


Lebron accomplished overall more than them, especially compared to West & Oscar... and also had the better championship run once again especially compared to West & Oscar... Oscar for example got that one and only championship way out of his prime being a 2nd fiddle to a 35-17-5 MVP&FMVP behemoth called Kareem... then there is that thing called player domination & impact, being the best player in the NBA for a couple of years (which none of those other players you see above were) and also his stats, milestones, records more than matches up any of those players....


So, would you be so kind to explain how that "is not right"?

[DTreats]

Junk removed

[Alan Ogg]

All Star MVP? I often see that on this site as a category when ranking players. That has to be one of the most meaningless achievements when comparing the greats. It just doesn't fit in with everything else.

[Horatio33]

Dr J.

[coin24]

All Star MVP? I often see that on this site as a category when ranking players. That has to be one of the most meaningless achievements when comparing the greats. It just doesn't fit in with everything else.

Anything pauk can use to prop up bronzey he will do. Shameless

[arifgokcen]

Anything pauk can use to prop up bronzey he will do. Shameless

Dude i dont like pauk but even if you remove all star mvps and Player of the month awards lebron resume is more impressive than any other #11-20 player.

[coin24]

Dude i dont like pauk but even if you remove all star mvps and Player of the month awards lebron resume is more impressive than any other #11-20 player.

Pippen>lebron 6>1

Yeah in all honesty lebron will be up there at the end of his career, it's just a bit too early to call. Anything could happen. 1 decent year after a career of underachieving/choking and being on a super team in a depleted conference just isnt enough IMO.. If they can repeat then its a whole other story...

[Kews1]

Pippen>lebron 6>1

Yeah in all honesty lebron will be up there at the end of his career, it's just a bit too early to call. Anything could happen. 1 decent year after a career of underachieving/choking and being on a super team in a depleted conference just isnt enough IMO.. If they can repeat then its a whole other story...

I understand that he didn't win a championship up until this year but seriously you can't call 3 x MVP underachieving, if he hadn't of won a championship this year then maby but I'm fairly sure that he's on par with where he should be right now...

[Rolando]

Dr. J

[INDI]

well technically it was requested to just vote, but to answer your question dr.J was already argued over Oscar and West, to bring it up now is too repetative and almost irrelevant

You can't discredit a mans ability and take away some of his prime years because there was two leagues back then. He played for the nets which became a nba team anyway, so to say all nets players who played at this time career's don't count would be stupid. I view it as todays nfl conferences where alot of times teams don't even play against other teams. They are still in the same league but didnt get to meet.

also lets stop faking the funk, these threads are the greatest NBA players of alltime but I doubt most people even care if ABA statistics are included. Julius was that dude and lead a proffessional league in mvp's, championships etc....



A more fair comparison for those of you that refuse to use his ABA year is to take off the first 5 years of everyone that played and then see how they match up

[SilkkTheShocker]

To early for Dirk

Dirk >>>>> KG


Give me the lead dog