Tracy Mcgrady vs Paul Pierce vs Vince Carter vs Allen Iverson in the 2000's

[Duncan21formvp]

Rank them from best to worst?

[WeaponX2024]

1. Pierce
2. Iverson
3. Carter
4. McGrady

Based off of success and accomplishments of this decade.

[NASH = BEST]

3b. Air Canada
3a. Crazy Eye Mcgrady
2. Bubba Chucks (MVP + Finals appearance)
1. Paul Pierce (Finals MVP + Ring)

Vince and Mcgrady were pretty much even in the last decade, both had a lot of let downs. In fact thats all I remember when I think of both of them dudes, LET DOWNS!!

[L.Kizzle]

1. Pierce
2. Iverson
3. Carter
4. McGrady

Based off of success and accomplishments of this decade.

AI
Mac
PP
VC

[Juges8932]

Accomplishments:
1)Pierce (I hate to say it, but I think FMVP and a Ring are most important)
2)AI (MVP+finals)
3)VC
4)TMAC

Physical abilities/prime:
1)TMAC
2A)AI
2B)VC
3) Pierce

[Revelation]

Accomplishments:
1)Pierce (I hate to say it, but I think FMVP and a Ring are most important)
2)AI (MVP+finals)
3)VC
4)TMAC

Physical abilities/prime:
1)TMAC
2A)AI
2B)VC
3) Pierce

Agreed. Strange how the most talented and "best" player of the bunch was the least successful.

[Juges8932]

Agreed. Strange how the most talented and "best" player of the bunch was the least successful.

No kidding. He could very well have gone down very high in the all-time rankings with all that potential. Too bad he got plagued by injuries and some would say, laziness. I'm a fan of all of them, except for Pierce. Disappointing that none of them really did anything aside from Pierce.

[WeaponX2024]

AI
Mac
PP
VC

McGrady above Pierce? I would understand Iverson, but McGrady? Don't give me that give McGrady a stacked team crap either, because even McGrady himself said something like that. You can talk about your All-NBA teams, but Pierce is above Tmac and there's nothing that supports Tmac.

[phoenix18]

Depressing thread. I would have AI at number one since he's a top 30 player, but what do I know?

[HylianNightmare]

Paul Pierce
AI
Vince
Tmac

[L.Kizzle]

McGrady above Pierce? I would understand Iverson, but McGrady? Don't give me that give McGrady a stacked team crap either, because even McGrady himself said something like that. You can talk about your All-NBA teams, but Pierce is above Tmac and there's nothing that supports Tmac.

PP was a noob until two seasons ago.

[WeaponX2024]

PP was a noob until two seasons ago.

Sorry, but the dude was somewhat playoff successful before Garnett and Allen came around. He led his team to the Eastern Conference Finals, I don't recall that happening with McGrady, I don't recall him even touching the 2nd round. Sorry man, I'm sure you really like McGrady but Pierce just blows him straight out the water.

[Mark Madsen]

Iverson
Mac/VC
PP

[hawksdogsbraves]

AI
Pierce
McGrady
Carter

I really don't see how you can put Pierce in front of AI, sure he has a title and finals mvp but that was on a stacked team and he barely won finals mvp over Ray Allen if you remember.

AI is a top 30 player of all time, on another level from these other guys in my opinion.

[WeaponX2024]

AI
Pierce
McGrady
Carter

I really don't see how you can put Pierce in front of AI, sure he has a title and finals mvp but that was on a stacked team and he barely won finals mvp over Ray Allen if you remember.

AI is a top 30 player of all time, on another level from these other guys in my opinion.

It's better than winning nothing in the Finals.