Let's clear the air on the REAL definition of a "star."

[ArbitraryWater]

My god brother... you're logic is horrible.

*your

[russwest0]

*your

lol thanks

[RoundMoundOfReb]

My god brother... you're logic is horrible.

your*

and please point out how exactly?

Let me rephrase this in terms you may understand:

You: If the person CAN run a 40 yard dash in under 4.4 seconds, he's "fast." If he CAN'T do that, then he isn't. It's as simple as that.

*Then Jason Terry runs a 4.35*

You: He's not fast.

Either A) Accept that he's fast or B) Admit your initial criteria (the premise of this thread) is total bullshit

[russwest0]

You said, IN THE OP, that if you can win as 2nd option on a title team, you're a star... WHICH IS WHAT PARKER DID IN 2007.

So basically your OP is a pile of and you just decide who was a 2nd option or not, fitting to your agenda.. right? Because obviously you don't give a damn about the "criteria" laid out in the OP. Otherwise Parker would be a star.

Again, you never once posted me saying that every championship team needs a "star" as their first and/or second option.

[ArbitraryWater]

lol thanks

It wasn't friendly advice but more so laughing at your dumb ass since you're American

[russwest0]

"If you're a woman, you're a bad driver."

"HURR DURR, RUSS SAID ALL BAD DRIVERS ARE WOMEN!!!!"

My god lol, some of yall on ISH have me losing brain cells some times

[ArbitraryWater]

Again, you never once posted me saying that every championship team needs a "star" as their first and/or second option.

Wait, what? That doesn't even matter... You said EVERY 2ND OPTION ON A TITLE TEAM = STAR... That's what you said... Players who can win as 2nd option can be labeled stars... So, Otis Thorpe, Tony Parker and Jason Terry, are STARS.... Or at least were.

You might as well own up to your flawed way of thinking instead of further embarrassing yourself.

Essentially your criteria is worthless because you don't apply it to every case... You just pick out the ones you like. When you say a 2nd option on a title team is a star, than that DOES mean every 2nd option, ever... Totally different than your retarded 'bad drivers / women' example.

[russwest0]

It wasn't friendly advice but more so laughing at your dumb ass since you're American

Yeah? That's cool bro

[Nash]

Lebron and Kobe = Superstars

The allstars and borderline allstars=Stars

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Again, you never once posted me saying that every championship team needs a "star" as their first and/or second option.

Except for the fact that you've defined a "star" as being the first/second option on a title team..

it's like me defining a hardcore basketball fan as somebody who posts on insidehoops and then saying ArbritraryWater is not a hardcore basketball fan...it makes no sense

[ArbitraryWater]

Except for the fact that you've defined a "star" as being the first/second option on a title team..

it's like me defining a hardcore basketball fan as somebody who posts on insidehoops and then saying ArbritraryWater is not a hardcore basketball fan...it makes no sense

[RoundMoundOfReb]

"If you're a woman, you're a bad driver."

"HURR DURR, RUSS SAID ALL BAD DRIVERS ARE WOMEN!!!!"

My god lol, some of yall on ISH have me losing brain cells some times

That is not even close to an accurate analogy...

it's more like you saying:

All women are bad drivers

but

Martha Stewart is a good driver...

makes no sense

[russwest0]

That is not even close to an accurate analogy...

it's more like you saying:

All women are bad drivers

but

Martha Stewart is a good driver...

makes no sense

Martha Stewart doesn't play in the NBA...

[ArbitraryWater]

Martha Stewart doesn't play in the NBA...

But bad female drivers do?

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Martha Stewart doesn't play in the NBA...

All stars are players who have the capability of being 1st or 2nd options on title teams

but

Jason Terry (who was a second option on a title team so he was clearly capable of being one) was not a star

makes no sense