David Robinson or Tim Duncan

[Bigsmoke]

I can NEVER and i repeat... NEVER can make up my mind in this comparison. Its like I wanted to say Duncan since he won titles without David but he won them when Jordan was not in the league besides in 2003 and when Hakeem became old as hell. Plus its like David Robinson was a bigger factor and more of a challege to guard than Duncan.... atleast to me. People may say that David isnt better because he got his ass beat by Hakeem... wouldnt Hakeem do that same **** on Duncan if Duncan was him right now back in 95? As slow as Duncan is, i really dont think he can guard Hakeem any better... but still... not sure who to pick between the 2...

Robinson when he scored 71
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUn7BvZ-4ZQ

Tim Duncan mix
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uN9FQ3RGjX8

[iTruWarrior]

I enjoyed watching Robinson more, but Duncan is the greater player.

Stats = Temporary thing
Stats + Rings = All-time thing
PER = GOAT

[ruslan]

Are you seriously asking this question? Duncan is the reason Robinson has rings.

[Bigsmoke]

I enjoyed watching Robinson more, but Duncan is the greater player.

Stats = Temporary thing
Stats + Rings = All-time thing
PER = GOAT

he's better and getting his teamates involved but David Robinson is one if not the greatest defensive player ever who can average 30 points per game

[Bigsmoke]

Are you seriously asking this question? Duncan is the reason Robinson has rings.

... i know that. But Robinson was already 34 and all injured up when he won his first ring.

[Maniak]

Tim Duncan all day every day.

Duncan is the GOAT at his position....

[Bush4Ever]

Robinson's game dropped in the playoffs.

Duncan's game raised in the playoffs during the critical times (37/16 against the Shaq Lakers and a near quadruple double against the Nets in the Finals)

When you are talking about the elite of the elite players, playoffs performances should count for much more than anything related to the regular season.

Duncan in a walk.

[iTruWarrior]

Robinson's game dropped in the playoffs.

Duncan's game raised in the playoffs during the critical times (37/16 against the Shaq Lakers and a near quadruple double against the Nets in the Finals)

When you are talking about the elite of the elite players, playoffs performances should count for much more than anything related to the regular season.

Duncan in a walk.

What up B4ever, You tired of ESPN already?

[Micku]

Robinson is probably the better individual player and Duncan is the better team player?

[Bush4Ever]

What up B4ever, You tired of ESPN already?

Yeah, that place has gone to the dogs. Even more so than usual.

I'll try this place out. Probably be in and out.

[Bush4Ever]

Robinson is probably the better individual player and Duncan is the better team player?

I think when we are evaluating elite players like this, the performances in the playoffs need to count for almost everything.

And Duncan takes any measure of performance in the playoffs, team, individual, or otherwise.

[iTruWarrior]

Yeah, that place has gone to the dogs. Even more so than usual.

I'll try this place out. Probably be in and out.

It's MeMacFan by the way..... Or are you just banned over there?

[Maniak]

Yeah, that place has gone to the dogs. Even more so than usual.

I'll try this place out. Probably be in and out.

If you are wanting to stay, try to ignore the trolls. If you avoid them and stick to talking to the smart ones, they will just fade away and become a distant voice. I wont list all trolls out, because they are easy enough to identify.

You seem like a smart and good poster though, welcome to ISH.

[Bush4Ever]

It's MeMacFan by the way..... Or are you just banned over there?

I see. No, I'm not banned. I've pretty much stopped posting there over the last 3 months.

[Sir Charles]

Prime Robinson > Duncan....

That is even thoug I Consider Him the Bigges ***** Girly Player Ever...He Was Just So Much More Talented and Athletic than Duncan