Is Dirk the most overrated player on ISH?

[navy]

.
Dirk was much better defensively and considerably better offensively given the circumstances, it is quite obvious for anybody who watched at least two damn games of that series

[HoopsFanNumero1]

You really don't watch games, and base the evaluations of players on stats, there's literally nothing to talk to you about basketball besides numbers, because that's the only way you could imply, that Wade was on Dirk's level or beyond.
Dirk was much better defensively and considerably better offensively given the circumstances, it is quite obvious for anybody who watched at least two damn games of that series

Dirk? Defense?

Yeah, you're a clown.

[ThePhantomCreep]

Eh, it's probably Duncan.

Dude even gets rated above Bird and Magic by a bunch of posters. When was his last 20/10 season again?

[red1]

You really don't watch games, and base the evaluations of players on stats, there's literally nothing to talk to you about basketball besides numbers, because that's the only way you could imply, that Wade was on Dirk's level or beyond.
Dirk was much better defensively and considerably better offensively given the circumstances, it is quite obvious for anybody who watched at least two damn games of that series

You are one of the least informed posters on this board. Everything you post is wrong

[fpliii]

Please watch the games before making a fool out of yourself in front of everybody

Is this real life?

[fpliii]

You really don't watch games, and base the evaluations of players on stats, there's literally nothing to talk to you about basketball besides numbers, because that's the only way you could imply, that Wade was on Dirk's level or beyond.
Dirk was much better defensively and considerably better offensively given the circumstances, it is quite obvious for anybody who watched at least two damn games of that series

Shit like this is why other fanbases hate us on this board. ****ing check yourself, and don't respond to me again in the future until you educate yourself.

[Anaximandro1]

most overrated? Bird,Kobe,Garnett,Malone,Ewing,Webber...

Raw stats are skewed by pace. Advanced stats are more useful and reliable.

[TheMarkMadsen]

most overrated? Bird,Kobe,Garnett,Malone,Ewing,Webber...

Raw stats are skewed by pace. Advanced stats are more useful and reliable.

PER, Ort, Drgt

[riseagainst]

he led his team and destroyed the Miami Heat big 3 in their primes.

[Collie]

Name the other players who have at least 1 ring, 1 MVP and 1 FMVP.

You'll see that it's a pretty ****ing short list.

[nathanjizzle]

Hes definitely overrated. people put him up their with tim duncan, thats a joke. hes on KGs level.

[SCdac]

Overrated or not, OP is making some of the worst threads

[Collie]

Hes definitely overrated. people put him up their with tim duncan, thats a joke. hes on KGs level.

Haven't actually seen anyone place him in TD (top 10) territory. Most have him on the bottom half of the top 20 or a little past that, which is just about right.

[livingby3's]

Well he was once labelled one of the, if not the biggest choker ever before that 2011 performance. That ring changed many many opinions. That said, the path to his championship was probably underrated. He didn't only beat the Heat with big 3 in 6, but also LA n OKC with a combined record of 8-1 to emerge out west. That season alone boosted his status alot

[DMAVS41]

Hes definitely overrated. people put him up their with tim duncan, thats a joke. hes on KGs level.

Nobody puts Dirk on par with Duncan...I've never seen anyone do this.