Is Dirk the most overrated player on ISH?

[Cone]

hell no. most underrated if anything

lets see how his career would have turned out if he actually had a HOFer in his prime like all other 'greats'

[MavsSuperFan]

Karl Malone, Clyde Drexler, and Isiah Thomas are more overrated IMO.


11 Finals is definitely overrated. Outplayed by DWade except for a couple of 4th quarters.

His 11 playoffs as a whole were insane though.

Thats like saying if it wasnt for her tits upton would be average.

You are ignoring a significant factor.

[Clyde]

Dirk is one of the greatest players in History.

It will be a looooooooooooooooong time before we see another Dirk.....if we ever do.

[Basketbolero]

Exactly...posted this in another thread earlier;

Last 14 seasons for each player (not counting this year for Kobe)

Regular season

Kobe 28/6/5 55.6% TS 24.1 PER
Dirk 24/9/3 58.4% TS 24.2 PER

Playoffs

Kobe 28/5/5 54.3% TS 23.0 PER
Dirk 26/10/3 58.4% TS 24.7 PER

And Kobe played with better help over that time...even including the shit 06 and 07 teams.

When both were off the court;

Lakers were - 1.5 without Kobe during that time
Mavs were - 3.6 without Dirk during that time

But yea...he's way over-rated...

I don't find that stat much valuable to compare such different players and situations to be honest but Dirk is a guy that was close to Duncan and around KG's level in his prime and people act like it is a stupid comparison to make. That pisses me off.

[Dro]

hell no. most underrated if anything

lets see how his career would have turned out if he actually had a HOFer in his prime like all other 'greats'

Kobe?

[TheMarkMadsen]

Thats like saying if it wasnt for her tits upton would be average.

You are ignoring a significant factor.

which would be?

[HoopsFanNumero1]

Nah, he's properly rated. Now Kobe. He's overrated.

[Cone]

Kobe?

yup

[MavsSuperFan]

which would be?

In the case of how dirk performed vs wade, The 4th quarter performances of dirk in the 2011 finals.

[red1]

nah he's not overrated

[Patrick Chewing]

[Artillery]

This thread begins and ends with Kobe.

[SexSymbol]

Karl Malone, Clyde Drexler, and Isiah Thomas are more overrated IMO.


11 Finals is definitely overrated. Outplayed by DWade except for a couple of 4th quarters.

His 11 playoffs as a whole were insane though.

Please watch the games before making a fool out of yourself in front of everybody

[HoopsFanNumero1]

Please watch the games before making a fool out of yourself in front of everybody

You really are a moron.

[SexSymbol]

You really are a moron.

You really don't watch games, and base the evaluations of players on stats, there's literally nothing to talk to you about basketball besides numbers, because that's the only way you could imply, that Wade was on Dirk's level or beyond.
Dirk was much better defensively and considerably better offensively given the circumstances, it is quite obvious for anybody who watched at least two damn games of that series