Rank their peaks: Kobe, Durant, Wade, McGrady, and Dirk

[Electric Slide]

Rank their peaks from best to worst.

[EnoughSaid]

1) Wade
2) Kobe
3) T-Mac
4) Durant
5) Dirk

[Dr. Cheesesteak]

1. Kobe
2. Durant
3. TMac
4. Dirk
5. Wade

[StocktonFan]

Tmac
Kobe
Wade
Durant
Dirk

[kuniva_dAMiGhTy]

Wade ('09)
Kobe
Dirk
Durant
Mcgrady

Not sure if Durant has peaked yet, but you're splitting hairs after Kobe and Wade.

[Derivative]

1) Wade (09)
2) T-Mac (03)
3) Kobe (06)
4) Dirk (06)
5) Durant (12)

[Rysio]

peak wade >>> peak kobe? lol i'll take broken down on 1 leg kobe from 2010 over any wade any day. you stat nerds need to stop.

[WayOfWade]

peak wade >>> peak kobe? lol i'll take broken down on 1 leg kobe from 2010 over any wade any day. you stat nerds need to stop.

I almost never insult anyone, but you are stupid. Kobe stopped playing defense in 2010, and Wade has been better than Kobe every year since 2009 (except 2013). I wouldn't quite rank Wade's peak over Kobe's, I'd need to do more research, but you are going over the top with this.

[LEFT4DEAD]

There is very small amount of players who can compare with that 09' Wade, and I dont see any of them listed hier. I would take only couple of prime Jordan' seasons, prime Shaq's, 1 or 2 Lebron's over him and thats about it. Guy was incredible.

Wade 09



TMac


Kobe

Dirk
Durant

[lilblingy]

1. 06 Kobe
2. 09 Wade
3. 03 T-mac

4. 06 Dirk
5. 13 Durant

[Random_Guy]

There is very small amount of players who can compare with that 09' Wade, and I dont see any of them listed hier. I would take only couple of prime Jordan' seasons, prime Shaq's, 1 or 2 Lebron's over him and thats about it. Guy was incredible.

Wade 09



TMac


Kobe

Dirk
Durant

Agree with Wade, but IMHO dont really see TMac being ahead of Kobe, I hate the dude but 06Kobe and 3peat PO Kobe was quite the player. This doesnt take anything away from TMac, I just think Kobe was the better player. Cant go wrong with either one, but the gap isnt as big as you list anyway.

[Dr. Cheesesteak]

peak wade >>> peak kobe? lol i'll take broken down on 1 leg kobe from 2010 over any wade any day. you stat nerds need to stop.

I almost never insult anyone, but you are stupid. Kobe stopped playing defense in 2010, and Wade has been better than Kobe every year since 2009 (except 2013). I wouldn't quite rank Wade's peak over Kobe's, I'd need to do more research, but you are going over the top with this.

Yeah I don't quite get what's going on here... what "research" is there to do? ppl actually watch or attend games, right? We going by the eye test? Or is this based of stats only?

[Rysio]

There is very small amount of players who can compare with that 09' Wade, and I dont see any of them listed hier. I would take only couple of prime Jordan' seasons, prime Shaq's, 1 or 2 Lebron's over him and thats about it. Guy was incredible.

Wade 09



TMac


Kobe

Dirk
Durant

yea too bad he couldnt get past those incredible hawks in the playoffs. such a bad luck to run into an all time great team in the first round while having such a great season.

[LuigiChambles]

1. Kobe
2. Wade
3. Dirk
4. McGrady
5. Durant

I put Durant on 5 since his game will still improve and hasn't peak yet.

[WayOfWade]

Yeah I don't quite get what's going on here... what "research" is there to do? ppl actually watch or attend games, right? We going by the eye test? Or is this based of stats only?

Well, there is stats research, and there's watching. Stats aren't everything, they're a piece of the puzzle, same as the eye test. I've seen both players live on multiple occasions, and seen many highlights of each, this just isn't a topic I've taken time to really go over.