Magic Johnson, Larry Bird, Tim Duncan

[Lebron23]

Rank these players from Best to Worst.

[plowking]

Larry Bird
Tim Duncan
Magic Johnson

[Alan Ogg]

Magic
Bird
Duncan

[TheMilkyBarKid]

Bird
Magic
Duncan

[SHAQisGOAT]

Peak:
Bird
Magic
Duncan
(all close but extremely between Magic and Duncan because of defense, but I still would got Magic higher)

For (my) all-time list, it would be the same.

[moe94]

Bird
Duncan
Magic

[MMM]

Bird
Duncan
Magic

[Harison]

By impact and peak:

Bird
Duncan
Magic

By ranking:

Bird/Magic
Duncan

[Odinn]

Peak wise;
Larry Bird
Tim Duncan
Magic Johnson

Career wise;
Larry Bird
Magic Johnson
Tim Duncan

[ripthekik]

All above Lebron.

[fpliii]

Bird
Duncan
Magic

My ordering used to be flipped, but since learning more about these guys I've settled on the above. I don't think there's much else out there that would force me to reevaluate again, but I'm open to hearing any case.

[B-hoop]

Bird
Duncan
Magic

My ordering used to be flipped, but since learning more about these guys I've settled on the above. I don't think there's much else out there that would force me to reevaluate again, but I'm open to hearing any case.

What's your top 10 Goat list? Just curious

[Pointguard]

Magic had more control of the game than any player ever. No other player comes close in controlling pace, getting easy baskets and getting teammates involved. People talk about his defense but his record against great offensive teams was crazy because they knew an open style game meant Magic's powers would be unleashed. Even a disciplined Celtic offense made mistakes worrying about Magic"s defense to offense capability.

Duncan along with Magic and Russell should have the winning category over hyped. These guys had a real relationship with winning so it should be a real factor in evaluating them.

Bird had the most impressive peak but it was only three years and Magic"s pacing beat them once in that three year span. Bird was one the games most deadly offensive weapons ever.

That's my order.

[scm5]

It's crazy how little respect Magic is getting in this thread.

[fpliii]

What's your top 10 Goat list? Just curious

Don't have one, sorry.