Karl Malone or charles barkley?

[GIF REACTION]

I'm taking Karl.

[feyki]

Peak - Barkley

Career - Draw

Longevity - Karl

[GIF REACTION]

Peak - Malone

Career - Malone

Longevity - Malone

[lil jahlil]

Peak - Barkley

Career - Draw

Longevity - Karl

Peak - Barkley

Career - Karl

Longevity - Karl

My favorite of the 2 is Barkley.

[SHAQisGOAT]

Got Malone higher on my all-time list but in terms of peak Chuck has the edge.

[Round Mound]

1985-95 Barkley
1996-00 Malone

[GIF REACTION]

1985-95 Barkley
1996-00 Malone

Malone was better than Barkley in a few of the years from 85-95

[Hamtaro CP3KDKG]

Peak - Malone

Career - Malone

Longevity - Malone

Literally no one who watched both Chuck and Karl play consider Karl to have the better peak. Barkley was clearly more dominant but Karls defensive edge makes it closer. Peak Chuck has an argument for GOAT offensive PF only one on his level is Dirk whos prolly better for peak on offense

[Round Mound]

Malone was better than Barkley in a few of the years from 85-95

Raw Stats Are Close But Broken Down Stats PER; EFF; +/- etc Barkley Clearly Has The Edge Till The 95-96 season.

Barkley Was Better Than Malone In More Areas, Than Malone Was Better At.

[GIF REACTION]

Also Malone's best season > Barkley's best season

[Round Mound]

Also Malone's best season > Barkley's best season

Nope. Malone Scored More Because He Took like 6-7 FGAs PG More and He Scored Much Less Efficient. Play-Off Numbers? Malone is a 46% FG Shooter and Thats With Stockton Designing 70% Of His Offensive Play.

[24-Inch_Chrome]

Barkley.

[Gileraracer]

Malone all day every day.

H2H confirms that

[Round Mound]

Malone all day every day.

H2H confirms that

From 1985 to 1996 Head To Head (11 Years or Over 70% of Their Meetings). Barkley has edge statistcally in Scoring Per FGAs Taken (Scoring is 24.8 PPG for Malone and 22.8 PPG For Barkley With Malone Taken Way For FGAs PG and FG% is Barkley 51% Malone 49% BTW), Higher FG%, Way Higher 2-Point by 5% Maring (In The Paint), Rebounding, Assists and Steals:

Also Barkley Has A Higher PER, EFF, Win Share Per 48 Min, Plus/Minus, Diferential Scoring (Who Are Shot Jackers And Who Arent) etc.

Barkley`s Drop Off Only Comes In Less Than 30% of Their H2Hs From 1996 To 2000 = That Is, When Barkley Was A 3rd Option in Houston, Was Overweight, Was Back Injured, Was Knee Injured and Pretty Much A Role Player.

Barkley > Malone ages 21-32

Malone > Barkley ages 33-37.

BARKLEY > Stockton-To Malone Sloan System.

[feyki]

Literally no one who watched both Chuck and Karl play consider Karl to have the better peak. Barkley was clearly more dominant but Karls defensive edge makes it closer. Peak Chuck has an argument for GOAT offensive PF only one on his level is Dirk whos prolly better for peak on offense

True.

Barkley's prime nearly on young Jordan level , Karl's prime nearly on old Jordan level .

89-94 Barkley is two time mvp (Barkley had more 1th place votes than Magic , and then Barkley is 89-90 mvp for me and more tougher era than Karl's mvp's) and him level against Jordan is 32-10-5 . Karl's level against Jordan is 25-10-4 .