Vince Carter vs Tracy McGrady Who Was Better?

[BRabbiT]

carter

good basketball genes nonetheless. their mothers should have made atleast 10 more...

yeah. but to me, a bigger question is what kind of spoiled brat environment were they both raised in, that resulted in 2 of the L's biggest whiners??

[playtetris]

I'd just differentiate prime and peak...
Peak - McGrady
Prime - Carter
Career - Carter

/thread

[wang4three]

T-Mac.

[HylianNightmare]

Prime T-Mac
Career Carter

Wow I actually agree with you for once

[samballs]

Peak TMac was crazy good, Peak Carter was too. Thats way to close for me to decide. I think TMac's Peak lasted longer, but Carter's career has been better.

VC for entertainment

[liljohnnywall]

Peak TMac was crazy good, Peak Carter was too. Thats way to close for me to decide. I think TMac's Peak lasted longer, but Carter's career has been better.

VC for entertainment

this

[SLY]

Prime T-Mac
Career Carter

[SLY]

T-Mac at his peak was even better Kobe lmao this ain't even a question.

True

[lilojmayo]

Tmac is a bad man in 2003. One of the greatest individual seasons in NBA history.

[plowking]

Tmac is a bad man in 2003. One of the greatest individual seasons in NBA history.

Nope, not even close.

[NuggetsFan]

For there careers I'd go with Carter probably. But a peak of 32\6\6 is pretty incredible and is better than anything Carter put up.

[Lebron23]

Vince Carter

[D-Rose]

<<<<<<<<<<<<

[RaceBannana]

I think they are around the same level but i pick TMac, always liked his combination of Athleticism, skill and length.

[Celts34]

WTF are people in this thread are smoking. By what measure has Vince had a better career than T-mac? Neither has won jack, so the only way you can measure them is by accomplishments. And by everything except stupid all-star fan selections, T-mac has out done Vince. Do people realize T-mac has 7 All-NBA selection(4 of the seven were 1st or 2nd team selections btw)? Do people realize thats three times as many +1 as Vince has had? And out of the two times Vince made it, 1 was a 2nd team, the other a 3rd team. And T-mac had 2 scoring titles as well.

No f*ckin brainer T-mac was a much better player than Vince in every facet you want measure them by but athleticism(which was not anywhere near as big a difference as alot of people are trying to make it). T-mac was a better ball-handler, better scorer, better passer, and better rebounder. A early to mid 00's, healthy T-mac was a top 3-5 player in the league(When was the same thing said about Vince outside of Canada?)during that time. No discussion, T-mac was better.

How can anyone who watched them both play argue against that. T-mac was better than any swingman in the League in the early 00's not named Kobe