will dallas be the favorites if Melo signs with them?

[veilside23]

monta/calderon/harris
VC/monta/ellington
melo/ marion
dirk
dalembert/wright

i hope carlisle would stay.. one of the best coach in the nba...


what is their rank ?

just want to know a good analysis ..

[RoundMoundOfReb]

No. I don't think Melo's game fits well with that team.

[navy]

No.

[DMAVS41]

Ugh...hell no.

We'd be scary good offensively, but Melo doesn't fit well for us. That last thing we need is a ball stopper forward that is kind of a cancer.

Now, we somehow get Chandler and Melo...and don't lose anything key.

Then we can talk.

But running Dalembert/Blair/Wright back as our bigs next to Dirk will absolutely not be good enough.

[veilside23]

Ugh...hell no.

We'd be scary good offensively, but Melo doesn't fit well for us. That last thing we need is a ball stopper forward that is kind of a cancer.

Now, we somehow get Chandler and Melo...and don't lose anything key.

Then we can talk.

But running Dalembert/Blair/Wright back as our bigs next to Dirk will absolutely not be good enough.

but would you want melo or not ?

[Akrazotile]

What evidence is there anywhere that Carmelo is a difference maker?

I swear, this guy gets so much talk and hype for someone who has demonstrated no ability to get results in a 10+ year career.


You are not 'adding' to your offense by adding Carmelo, you are simply transferring the scoring from a group effort to a single individual, and for the Mavs that is a DOWNgrade.

I swear, people act like putting Carmelo on a team is going to simply add a net 25 points to their nightly total. Carmelo Anthony does not IMPROVE a team's scoring, he simply hogs it. Only the dumb fans are fooled by such a meaningless red herring. Its not a positive impact. Seriously, how many times do you have to tell people this??

[DMAVS41]

but would you want melo or not ?

Alone? hell no.

His money could be used to improve things we actually need.

You could get Deng and Pau Gasol or Deng and Asik for the same price...and that combo is way better than melo alone for this Mavs team.

[veilside23]

What evidence is there anywhere that Carmelo is a difference maker?

I swear, this guy gets so much talk and hype for someone who has demonstrated no ability to get results in a 10+ year career.

Well melo is still one of the best scorer in the game ... i dont know when would be the time that he would mature and understand his role as a superstar and take it to the next level..

[SCdac]

Offensively they'd be sick. They were a great offensive team this season, and I think Dirk and Melo would ultimately work. But, defense. Will they

[Cactus-Sack]

Their main need is a defensive C. Dirk and Monta are capable of shouldering the offensive load.

[Cactus-Sack]

Alone? hell no.

His money could be used to improve things we actually need.

You could get Deng and Pau Gasol or Deng and Asik for the same price...and that combo is way better than melo alone for this Mavs team.

God that's scary. Asik is perfect next to Dirk. Could go w/ a small-ball line-up of: Calderon-Ellis-Deng-Marion-Dirk.




Would be great to see Mavs-Spurs in the WCF next year. Such a good series this year.

[Trentknicks]

Ugh...hell no.

We'd be scary good offensively, but Melo doesn't fit well for us. That last thing we need is a ball stopper forward that is kind of a cancer.

Now, we somehow get Chandler and Melo...and don't lose anything key.

Then we can talk.

But running Dalembert/Blair/Wright back as our bigs next to Dirk will absolutely not be good enough.

He'd actually have options there moron Try actually watching the games.

[masonanddixon]

Deng and Asik/Gortat and Mavs become the favorites.

[GimmeThat]

monta/calderon/harris
VC/monta/ellington
melo/ marion
dirk
dalembert/wright

i hope carlisle would stay.. one of the best coach in the nba...


what is their rank ?

just want to know a good analysis ..

I'd put them up as close to a favorite as their is before the FA settles

Carlisle's coaching IS pretty impressive.


He can get Kidd to work with Dirk.
There's no saying he can't get that out of Melo.

[hawkfan]

Luol Deng and Jordan Hill are more realistic.
And that would improve the Mavs by about 5 more wins.