Andrew Bogut or Andrew Bynum

[Rhyen]

Bynum did play through an eff'd up knee in last year's playoffs, gotta give credit where credit's do (even though he's an idiot for not getting surgery sooner but it probably won't matter come playoff time).

Bynum's sheer size drastically alters opposing players' ability to get to the rim. Gasol isn't going to contest.. where as Bynum is a shot blocker fo sho

It would be interesting to see Bogut in the Laker's system, that would be able to give us a more comparible view on things. Bogut is definitly the better passer out of the post, it's hard for me to picture Bynum kick the ball out of the post.. ever.

[StacksOnDeck]

lol..Bynum sucks. Healthy or not.

Negged

[triangleoffense]

By far Andrew Bynum, even taking into account his injury proneness. Bynum when healthy is nearly as physical as Howard and even smarter offensively. He doesn't have near athleticism of Howard but as far as most physical centers in the league its pretty much Bynum/Howard and everyone else.

[blacknapalm]

i would have probably said bogut had a slight edge pre-elbow injury. i think that's messed him up more than he wants to let on. i mean, he still feels pain when he makes his arm go completely straight. now, it's bynum.

bogut is more mobile, the better passer and is the better closeout defender. bynum is tougher to guard inside due to his length, is the better rebounder currently and his sheer size reeks havoc in the paint.

[Cali Syndicate]

I'd call it a wash.

Bogut's d is better but only to the tune of Bynum's better offense. Both have advantages in certain areas but not to a point where one edges the other as an overall player.

I take Bynum tho just for his untapped potential due to playing alongside Kobe and Pau.

Bogut's a solid top 5 center no doubt.

[StacksOnDeck]

[305Baller]

bynum if he can stay healthy

I agree with Stuckey.

[Xiao Yao You]

Bogut if healthy. Most well rounded center there is.

[KBryant24]

you guys are dumb
bynum has finally been given the keys to the offense this year.
he is putting up 17-11
this is what he has been capable of when he gets an increase in touches

[roffie]

bynum anyday easily for me..

but i think its what the team needs more. if you got too many scorers, take bogut.

need points? take bynum.

but with that being said.. bynum is a much better overall player though, and you'll be a fool to pass him up for bogut.

[Xiao Yao You]

this is what he has been capable of when he gets an increase in touches

And being healthy for a change.

[SacJB Shady]

I have to cut in here. Regardless of the comparison, I think the Dubs have changed their identity. They have David Lee and Andrew Bogut.

[Bigsmoke]

real talk

Bynum now > Bogut whenever he was good.

[alenleomessi]

Serious talk, if you give Bynum 1st option touches he will average Howard type of numbers

[Xiao Yao You]

Assuming he's not hurt and isn't loafing around like the other night.