Karl Malone vs Charles Barkley vs Kevin Garnett vs Dirk Nowitzki

[Duncan21formvp]

How would you rank them in order from best to worst?

[EnoughSaid]

Malone
Barkley
Garnett
Nowitzki

[ThaSwagg3r]

Peak

1. KG
2. Barkley
3. Malone
4. Dirk

All-time list/Career

1. Malone
2. KG
3. Dirk
4. Barkley


I think Dirk will be ranked over KG in the all-time list when it's all said and done. Dirk has a lot left in the tank while KG's years as the franchise player are done and could retire in a few years.

[305Baller]

Barkley
Garnett
Malone
Nowitzki

[305Baller]

I really want to put Nowitzki over Malone.
But Im not sure head-to-head dirk could handle his physicality.

[knickswin]

Nowitzki
Barkley
Malone
Garnett

Sometimes I put Barkley ahead of Dirk depending on my mood. Dirk's got the ring and is probably the "greater" player, but Barkley is probably the better player.

[knickswin]

Peak

1. KG
2. Barkley
3. Malone
4. Dirk

All-time list/Career

1. Malone
2. KG
3. Dirk
4. Barkley


I think Dirk will be ranked over KG in the all-time list when it's all said and done. Dirk has a lot left in the tank while KG's years as the franchise player are done and could retire in a few years.

I would take peak Barkley over peak Garnett pretty easily, he was looking like potentially the GOAT offensive player.

[kurt_rambis]

barkley
KG
malone
dirk
chilcutt

[Jacks3]

Peak/prime

1. KG
2. Barkley
3. Malone


4. Dirk

[Sheed]

Kobe
Lebron
Jared Dudley
Quincy Douby

[DMAVS41]

They are all on the same tier. When its all said and done:

1. Dirk
2. KG
3. Malone
4. Barkley

[Swaggin916]

Garnett
Dirk
Malone
Barkley

Garnett is the only one who plays/played both ends well and has a ship. Dirk is the most unstoppable offensively and has a ship. Malone and Barkley were great players, but don't have ships... I think it's really that simple. Ships do a lot for you they really do, especially when it's close.

[Swaggin916]

I really want to put Nowitzki over Malone.
But Im not sure head-to-head dirk could handle his physicality.

He'd just shoot over his ass. Dirk shits on physical defenders now just way too skilled and beats them off the dribble.

[blablabla]

kg
barkley
dirk/malone

[get these NETS]

He'd just shoot over his ass. Dirk shits on physical defenders now just way too skilled and beats them off the dribble.

think he meant when malone has the ball....dirk would get abused all day every day by malone's physicality and skills, even though he's a good 3 inches taller with much longer wingspan