-
College superstar
(video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
-
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
He shouldn't have won in 06.
05 was just a weak year. Duncan didn't play enough games or minutes. But he was definitely the best player.
-
NBA Superstar
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Hes said it before on Open Court too. Any honest basketball fan feels the same
05 - Shaq
06 - Dirk
-
SexLand
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
He's said this millions of times.
-
NBA Legend
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
-
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by Hamtaro CP3KDKG
Hes said it before on Open Court too. Any honest basketball fan feels the same
05 - Shaq
06 - Dirk
how about the guy who outscored dirks team by himself that season
-
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by kennethgriffin
how about the guy who outscored dirks team by himself that season
Close second
-
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Shaq is right. Nash having any MVPs is a joke.
He's an excellent player and definitely deserved to make some all-star teams, but MVP? No.
-
ISH vigilant
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
I think 2005 was about right. 2006 is a toss-up between Nash and dirk. For me Nash deserved it though. He carried that team without Amare. Lebron is 3rd imo.
-
NBA Legend
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by midatlantic09
Shaq is right. Nash having any MVPs is a joke.
He's an excellent player and definitely deserved to make some all-star teams, but MVP? No.
If Rose and Curry can win MVP's than I have no problem with Nash winning it. This is the landscape of the modern NBA.
-
NBA Superstar
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by kennethgriffin
how about the guy who outscored dirks team by himself that season
Kobe was best player in 06 for sure but MVP has always took team wins into account and LA didn't win enough games
-
Heat Nation
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
If Nash doesn't win in 2005, thats fine, but Shaq didnt ****ing deserve it either. He was the 2nd best player on his team.
-
ISH vigilant
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by Papaya Petee
If Nash doesn't win in 2005, thats fine, but Shaq didnt ****ing deserve it either. He was the 2nd best player on his team.
In 2005? I think you'd have a better case in 06.
It's similar to how Wade just dropped a level from 2011 (when he was arguably Miami's best player ) till 2012 (when he was a considerable distance below lebron)
-
Wilt Davis
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Imagine if Cousy held Wilt and Russell to one MVP.
Wilt should have won in 61, doe.
-
Heat Nation
Re: (video)Shaq says Nash shouldn't have won 2 MVPs
Originally Posted by Mr Feeny
In 2005? I think you'd have a better case in 06.
It's similar to how Wade just dropped a level from 2011 (when he was arguably Miami's best player ) till 2012 (when he was a considerable distance below lebron)
No because in 06 its not even an argument
24/7/6/2/1 77 games regular season vs 23/10/3/2 73 games. Wade was the best scorer, playmaker, and defender that season.
27/7/6/2/1 14 playoff games vs 19/8/2/2 13 playoff games
05 Wade > 05 Shaq
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|