How many times do I have to post this? LeBron can very much be argued a better defender than Jordan. The stats back this up, he just had arguably the GOAT defensive finals performance
Kobe 1996: Didn't place
Kobe 1997: Didn't place
Kobe 1998: Didn't place
Kobe 1999: Didn't place
Kobe 2000: 5th
Kobe 2001: 11th
Kobe 2002: 3rd
Kobe 2003: 8th
Kobe 2004: 10th
Kobe 2005: Didn't place
Kobe 2006: Didn't place
Kobe 2007: 24th
Kobe 2008: 5th
Kobe 2009: 7th
Kobe 2010: 12th
Kobe 2011: 11th
Kobe 2012: Didn't place
Kobe 2013: Didn't place
Kobe 2014: Didn't place
Kobe 2015: Didn't place
Kobe 2016: Didn't place
LeBron 2004: Didn't place
LeBron 2005: Didn't place
LeBron 2006: Didn't place
LeBron 2007: Didn't place
LeBron 2008: Didn't place
LeBron 2009: 2nd
LeBron 2010: 4th
LeBron 2011: 9th
LeBron 2012: 4th
LeBron 2013: 2nd
LeBron 2014: 6th
LeBron 2015: 13th
LeBron 2016: 11th
Kobe in years placed average position: 10th
LeBron in years placed average position: 6th
Kobe's best 5 years: 3rd, 5th, 5th, 7th, 8th (Average of 6th)
LeBron's best 5 years: 2nd, 2nd, 4th, 4th, 6th (Average of 4th)
Kobe Career Defensive Win Shares: 50.7 (48637 minutes played)
LeBron Career Defensive Win Shares: 58.4 (38478 minutes played)
Kobe Career Defensive Box Plus Minus: -0.6
LeBron Career Defensive Box Plus Minus: +1.9
Kobe's best Defensive Win Shares season (4.5), is on par with LeBron's 8th best Defensive Win Shares season (4.5)
Kobe Career Defensive Rating: 105
LeBron Career Defensive Rating: 102
PLAYOFFS:
Kobe Career Defensive Rating: 106
LeBron Career Defensive Rating: 101
Kobe Career Defensive Win Shares: 7.3 (8641 minutes played)
LeBron Career Defensive Win Shares: 12.8 (7871 minutes played)
Kobe Career Defensive Box Plus Minus: +0.7
LeBron Career Defensive Box Plus Minus: +3.2
Kobe's best Defensive Win Shares playoff total (1.4), is on par with LeBron's 5th best Defensive Win Shares playoff total (1.4)
//
Even the most objective subjective analysis hands down favors LeBron
The only thing that won't favor LeBron is the opinion (subjective) of Kobe stans
LeBron is visually and empirically a better defender
Opponents' shooting against LeBron in Games 5, 6, and 7 in the Finals
Overall: 2.7/12.7, 21.1%, opponents usually shoot 47.9%, -26.8
Threes: .7/5, 13.3%, opponents usually shoot 40.4%; -27%
Twos: 2/7.7, 26.1%, opponents usually shoot 53.3%, -27.2%
Less than 6 ft: 1/5, 20%, opponents usually shoot 62.4%, -42.4%
Less than 10 ft: 1.3/6, 22.2%, opponents usually shoot 57.3%; -35.1%
Greater than 15 ft: 1/6.3, 15.8%; opponents usually shoot 40.5%; -24.7%
LeBron 2016 Playoffs (21 games)
3.2/10.2 Defensive FGs defended
Overall, held opponents to 31.8% FG (Their average FG% was 45.9%
This is a differential of
[COLOR="Red"]-14.1%[/COLOR] (He held opponents to -14.8% their average FG%), which is by far the best mark... For comparison, Draymond was next best at -8.4%
SOURCE:
http://stats.nba.com/defensivehub/#!...?sort=GP&dir=1
To break it down even further to perimeter defense and Rim protection..
3PT DEFENSE
LeBron was the Cavs best 3pt defender, and along with Livingtson and context taken into account, the best 3pt defenders
0.9/3.8 Defensive Field Goals Defended
Held opponent 3pt shooters to 24.1% (Their average 3PT% was 36.7%)
This is a differential of
[COLOR="Red"]-12.6%[/COLOR]
Only one guy who played 15+ playoff games (Shawn Livingston) had a slightly better differential (Abet on lower volume)
SOURCE:
http://stats.nba.com/defensivehub/#!...USMINUS&dir=-1
RIM PROTECTION
1.4/3.3 Defensive Field Goals Defended
Held opponents at the rim to 43.5%
[COLOR="Blue"]
The best rim protection % on the Cavs[/COLOR]
For reference Bogut held opponents to 46.6%, and Tristan Thompson 49.2%
SOURCE:
http://stats.nba.com/defensivehub/#!...&sort=GP&dir=1
...
Here's also some stuff comparing him and DPOY winner Kawhi Leonard in the regular season;
The usual field goal percent of the shooter that the player is defending
LeBron - 44.8%
Kawhi - 44.9%
Defense Dashboard
2pt FGs - Players shot 8.2% worse than their average when defended by LeBron
2pt FGs - Players shot 7.3% worse than their average when defended by Kawhi
3pt FGs - Players shots 2.7% worse than their average when defended by LeBron
3pt FGs - Players shot 1.3% worse than their average when defended by Kawhi
Overall - Players shot 7.4% worse than their average when defended by LeBron on 8.4 Defended FGs Per Game
Overall - Players shot 5.7% worse than their average when defended by Kawhi on 9.4 Defended FGs Per Game
Play type
When they were the closest isolation defender
LeBron - 69 possessions, .59 points per possession allowed, 28.8% eFG
Kawhi - 61 possessions, .69 points per possession allowed, 31% eFG
When they were the closest defender to the PnR ball handler
LeBron - 144 possessions, .66 ppp allowed, 37.1 eFG
Kawhi - 243 possessions, .65 ppp allowed, 35.8 eFG
When they were the roll man defender
LeBron - 10 possessions, .7 ppp, 38.9 eFG
Kawhi - 30 possessions, .5 ppp, 27.8 eFG
Post defense
LeBron - 43 possessions, .77 ppp, 40 eFG
Kawhi - 31 possessions, .77 ppp, 41.7 eFG
On spot up shooters
LeBron - 210 possessions, .8 ppp, 41.6 eFG
Kawhi - 200 possessions, .88 ppp, 43.6 eFG
Hand-offs
LeBron - 43 possessions, .49 ppp, 33.9 eFG
Leonard - 58 possessions, .72 ppp, 39.5 eFG
Off screens
LeBron - 78 possessions, .74 ppp, 40.8 eFG
Kawhi - 96 possessions, 1.05 ppp, 51.2 eFG
Finals Averages...
2.3 Blocks a game
2.6 Steals a game
2016 Playoff Averages
2.3 Steals a game
1.3 Blocks a game
In the last 3 games,
[COLOR="Red"]LeBron averaged 3 blocks and 3 steals per game[/COLOR]
[COLOR="Blue"]LeBron had the second highest playoff DPM (5.8) in a championship winning playoff run of all time only behind Ben Wallace in '04 (6.0)[/COLOR]