Should having more than 1 all star teammate knock you out of mvp consideration?

[The Iron Fist]

If you have three all stars on one team, how valuable can you really be?

[TheMarkMadsen]

look at the records w/o that player/ the other all star

[Ca$H]

If you have three all stars on one team, how valuable can you really be?

Yes. LeBron's 2 MVPs with the Heat are ridiculous. Most valuable. LOL. I respect his 2 MVPs with the cavs though.

[Dro]

Good question. I'm not really sure....

[Warfan]

No

[Milbuck]

look at the records w/o that player/ the other all star

Precisely why Durant should be MVP, without a doubt. That period without Westbrook was just incredible.

[red1]

Yes. LeBron's 2 MVPs with the Heat are ridiculous. Most valuable. LOL. I respect his 2 MVPs with the cavs though.

I see what you mean but at the same time who in the league was more valuable during those two years? Nobody tbh.

[pegasus]

Everybody knows this. Even Lebron said in 2011, ironically when Wade was getting MVP talks for his great play in January (or February), that they eliminate each other from the MVP race. But then somehow the media found a reason to give him 2 MVP's, just because Wade chose to sit out easy games and played against the tough opponents. They tried the same thing this year but Lebron fell flat on his face with or without Wade.

[TheMilkyBarKid]

Precisely why Durant should be MVP, without a doubt. That period without Westbrook was just incredible.

Barring an amazing lbj run to end the season yes. Still kd is #2 till he proves otherwise.

[Jlamb47]

It shouldnt knock the player out without looking at the situation and record etc.
but i feel like a player with less superstar players with close or better records should get it if there stats meet

[Quickening]

I think being a rapist should keep you out the HOF

[ripthekik]

It's funny because without him, Wade and Bosh would go to the ECF at the minimum every year. What kind of MVP is it when your team can get to the conference finals without you?

[Clyde]

I think being a rapist should keep you out the HOF

If someone were convicted of said crime they probably would.

[Quickening]

If someone were convicted of said crime they probably would.

Hitler was never convicted of anything either, both good men...

[Clyde]

Hitler was never convicted of anything either, both good men...

wow.