Is Manu Ginobili top 10 SG all time?

[KnittingRyu]

bolded are debatable. i think manus better than miller, ray, vince. Hes better than west for sure today, and might be better than wade.

[Fallen Angel]

I classify Allen Iverson as a PG when doing my All-Time list. Either way, Manu Ginobili is a Top 15 SG All-Time when you factor in his accomplishments oversees, which is impressive for player who is a career sixth man in the NBA.

[zeerghit]

MODS, ban this fool.

Manu is a legend for getting carried to titles. GTFO here b.

retard. end of story.

[WayOfWade]

HOF ranking on BBR.com


#1 Michael Jordan 1.0000
#2 Kobe Bryant 1.0000
#3 Jerry West 1.0000
#4 Dwyane Wade 0.9999
#5 Allen Iverson 0.9998
#6 Sam Jones 0.9995
#7 Ray Allen 0.9987
#8 Clyde Drexler 0.9978
#9 Hal Greer 0.9974
#10 Bill Sharman 0.9970

HM George Gervin 0.9787



this is probably closer to the truth than most would like to believe.




people seem to only be able to name guys from the 90's


the IQ of this forum is sh*t

This seems like the most correct comment so far. The order of the top 10 is very good; not quite sure how the ranking system goes, but seeming like a Hall of Fame likeliness chart, I'd say it's pretty good. Jordan, Kobe, and West are a very good top 3 with Wade being the only challenger to West's 3 spot. The only one I'm not sure about is Sam Jones, that due to me being young and never seeing him play or reading too much about him. Good post though

[KnittingRyu]

HOF ranking on BBR.com


#1 Michael Jordan 1.0000
#2 Kobe Bryant 1.0000
#3 Jerry West 1.0000
#4 Dwyane Wade 0.9999
#5 Allen Iverson 0.9998
#6 Sam Jones 0.9995
#7 Ray Allen 0.9987
#8 Clyde Drexler 0.9978
#9 Hal Greer 0.9974
#10 Bill Sharman 0.9970

HM George Gervin 0.9787



this is probably closer to the truth than most would like to believe.




people seem to only be able to name guys from the 90's


the IQ of this forum is sh*t

Of the players I'm more familiar with, this looks pretty accurate.

[SHAQisGOAT]

On the all-time list? Probably so, has a great case at least.

In terms of peaks/primes? Don't think so... For consideration, you got dudes like Jordan, Kobe, West, Wade, Drexler, Gervin, Iverson, Moncrief, T-Mac (if you consider him more of a SG), Pistol Pete, Carter, David Thompson, DJ (more of a SG at his best), Monroe, Westphal, Reggie, Dumars, Richmond...

[ArbitraryWater]

Jordan
Kobe
Wade
West
Drexler
Iverson
T-Mac
Miller
Ray
Vince

All better

I'd take Manu over Vince and Miller (lol cmon) easily, also Ray.. T-Mac obviously career wise too, but at his peak (2003) he was better.

[BasedTom]

bolded are debatable. i think manus better than miller, ray, vince. Hes better than west for sure today, and might be better than wade.

[Vaniiiia]

MODS, ban this fool.

Manu is a legend for getting carried to titles. GTFO here b.

lol, get a life you corny looking homo. You've never played a sport in your life.

Your opinions don't matter here. Ferry's like you don't belong here. Carter couldn't even get "carried to titles" ... let alone lead or be a significant contributor to a championship ring. Iverson? Ha, no way, outside of 2001 where he was carried and allowed to chuck, dude was mainly a cancer and literally prevented teams from ever creating the appropriate atmosphere to win a championship. A gambling, bumbling moron of a man. A cancer in its truest and most lethal form.

Reggie Miller? Ray Allen?

OVER MANU?

Are you f[COLOR="Black"]uck[/COLOR]ing retarded? I guess being sheltered your whole life prevented YOU from ever developing critical thinking skills, or even basic common sense. Your dad should've forced you into joining a sports team or something. You've grown to be such an annoying little punk. And an even bigger loser.

Damn shame.

[Legends66NBA7]

I'd take Manu over Vince and Miller (lol cmon) easily, also Ray.. T-Mac obviously career wise too, but at his peak (2003) he was better.

They were all better at their peak than Manu.

It's hard to define Manu because he never got the chance to lead his own team like the others did. You take Manu over all those guys if he has a situation like he had in SA, which in itself is unique in all sports.

[Legends66NBA7]

lol, get a life you corny looking homo. You've never played a sport in your life.

Your opinions don't matter here. Ferry's like you don't belong here.

[lilteapot]

bolded are debatable. i think manus better than miller, ray, vince. Hes better than west for sure today, and might be better than wade.

There's no way Manu is better than Wade.

[Lebronxrings]

There's no way Manu is better than Wade.

both have fmvps, and won the ring as the leader and man. Skillwise they're quite similar. Manu beats Wade in terms of longetitvity, wade wins in peak.

[Fallen Angel]

Mods, please do something about the ignorant fools in this forum.

[kennethgriffin]

[QUOTE=Fallen Angel]Hal Greer:

NBA champion (1967)
10