Better Nba career: Manu Ginobili vs Melo

[greatest-ever]

Sort of a random comparison, but who had the better career based on only Nba?For a while i thought Melo, but now i think id have to side with Manu, he has 4 titles(2 of which he was a top 20 player in the league at minimum) and was a more all around player than melo, actually passes and plays defense. I guess the argument against Manu would be his lack of durability, and inability to play heavy minutes.

[Prime_Shaq]

Is this a joke?
Manu's career >>>>>>> Melo's career

[ShawkFactory]

Pretty clearly Manu..

[greatest-ever]

Is this a joke?
Manu's career >>>>>>> Melo's career

I wouldn't call it a joke. I got both players in my top 70-80 range. I can see an argument for either one going strictly by nba.

[Jud]

Lol... obviously Ginobili. He has more awards and is actually a TEAM PLAYER

[Optimus Prime]

Ginoboli and it's not even close.

[Straight_Ballin]

Manu

/thread now please

[christian1923]

Manu

I'd rather have Melos career then manu's though

[Budadiiii]

Easily Melo.

[L.Kizzle]

Carmelo.

What next Joe Dumars better than Dominique Wilkins because he won titles?

[imdaman99]

I think if Melo got drafted and put in a great situation, he would have rings too. For example, if this dumbass Joe Dumars didn't pick that tall white stiff? Melo would have at least 1 ring and the Pistons would be headed in the right direction. Instead he tried to outsmart everyone and picked that scrub and Pistons became shit for a number of years. Isiah Thomas did the same to the Knicks. Piston legends as GMs

I like Ginoblis game better though. He has always been the Spurs best passer.

[Taller than CP3]

If you want to compare Melo to someone, then you can compare him to Andrew Wiggins, another guy with zero rings.

[SCdac]

Uhh, just thinking about Melo's ugly departure from Denver and forgetful seasons in NYC makes me want Manu's career - a winner on basically every level. Keep in mind they're both multi millionaires and Manu is basically a god when he goes back to Argentina. If we want to talk about 'scoring ability', and that only, sure I think Melo probably wins that argument. But Manu's career has been superb - relative to some of his national buddies like Andres Nocioni or Carlos Delfino

[Akrazotile]

OP seriously, watchu smokin on dawg?

[pastis]

I wouldn't call it a joke. I got both players in my top 70-80 range. I can see an argument for either one going strictly by nba.

what did melo archieved for being top 70 all time.