Chris Paul or Jason Kidd?

[Draz]

Did I say something stupid?

[Ronaldinho]

Kidd. I know the stat nerds don't like hearing it, but his impact goes way beyond the box score.

This. Kidd. I like CP3, but Kidd is just better.

[Thechosen1]

cp3 before injury was the best point guard ever without a ring

[Nikola_]

CP3 after injury

[KyrieTheFuture]

Kidd, I feel he's easier to build around. CP3 presents you with the problem of him running the entire show, and PGs just aren't that important. Kidd I personally feel could accept a second option role much easier.

[JohnFreeman]

I would take Kidd now, over CP0

[Mass Debator]

I like CP3's shooting and fiery mentality, but Kidd's versatility in guarding 1s, 2s, and sometimes 3s is what gives him the edge to me.

Honestly, leading a franchise, I pick J Kidd...but as a second option, I'm going with CP3.

[swagga]

Chris Paul. Better scorer, passer, and just as good of a defender.

kidd regularly checked WINGS... even at 40 he checked lebron in the finals in 2011 ... their defensive impact is not even in the same league

[Xiao Yao You]

Paul

[tmacattack33]

Chris Paul before his injury in 2009 > Jason Kidd in the early 2000's > Current Chris Paul

[Crown&Coke]

JKidd was a different animal, he was the reason I wanted to be a 6'4 point guard. I just couldn't learn how to grow in height

[navy]

Kidd took less talented teams further. Kidd for many reasons

In the Eastern Conference....

[Leroy Jetson]

Kidd, better all around especially on defense. Much more successful in the playoffs when it counted.

[J Shuttlesworth]

I'll take Kidd, but it's pretty damn close

[r0drig0lac]