now that Peyton Manning has broken another record yet again

[dude77]

As lifelong Broncos fan who appreciates Peyton I have him ranked 4th atm but he is close to surpassing both Tom Brady and John Elway at this current pace, Manning to me even if he retires with only one SB win. But after four neck surgery's sitting out entire 2011 season if you would of told me Manning would be playing at MVP level in his late 30's doing this I would of thought you were crazy. I believe when it's all said and done he retires 2nd best QB in NFL history unless Brady wins another SB and Peyton does not.

I can go with this .. I forgot about his neck problems for a minute there(says a lot about how he's playing) .. his abilities or whatever was left of it was in major doubt at that point and I don't think anyone ever thought he would be as good as his former self let alone explode like he did .. very impressive

[CelticBaller]

Peyton Manning is the greatest of all-time.

Took 2 franchises to the Super Bowl. Took 3 different coaches to the Super Bowl. It's really just Peyton Manning vs the other team for much of his career. That's why his playoff/postseason record isn't that great.

Brady was a slightly above system QB when he won his 3 Super Bowl. It was Belichick, their defense and spying more than anything.

And the only SB peyton ever won was because of his defense... I mean can you please post peyton SB stats that year? or his post season stats?

and at Brady being a slighty above QB, dude put up a 92 passer rating in his back to back SB seasons

[ArbitraryWater]

I don't see any way Brady is better than Manning... lol sorry.

[bigkingsfan]

Can't lose 43-8 and throw a game ending pick 6 in the SB to be considered the best.

[CelticBaller]

I don't see any way Brady is better than Manning... lol sorry.

Brady has the stats AND the rings

[Nanners]

Brady has the stats AND the rings

Brady does have the rings, but Peyton is ahead of him in almost every statistical category.

[CelticBaller]

Brady does have the rings, but Peyton is ahead of him in almost every statistical category.

But Brady doesn't need to be ahead in most of them, the fact that he has put up great stats while also winning superbowls is what really stands

Maybe he didn't win it in his best years, but he never stank it up like Manning when they offense ran through them. His 2 superbowl losses came from plays out of his reach, of course the were small mistakes but unlike Brady, Manning has deliberately cause his team the big L

[ThePhantomCreep]

The ring argument doesn't work as well in football as it does in basketball--Peyton Manning doesn't have nearly as much control over his own destiny as LeBron James. He doesn't play defense or special teams.

[ThePhantomCreep]

Can't lose 43-8 and throw a game ending pick 6 in the SB to be considered the best.

That's pretty arbitrary. Did you know Joe Montana has a 49-3 playoff loss on his resume? Besides the fact that his numbers are vastly inferior to Manning's?

[Patrick Chewing]

The people rating Montana and Brady above Manning are just dumb.


These are the same people that rate Bill Russell in the Top 5 or as the GOAT.


Peyton Manning is the best QB of all time. No one Quarterback has been able to accomplish what he has. Period.

[CelticBaller]

The ring argument doesn't work as well in football as it does in basketball--Peyton Manning doesn't have nearly as much control over his own destiny as LeBron James. He doesn't play defense or special teams.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JM6I7AjCFAY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y63VDL_t_o

but he didn't have as much control

[Bless Mathews]

Lol. Lol.


Peyton manning best regular season Qb ever.


1 - 2 in superbowls. Only one he won against Rex fuccin gross man. Lol.


8 FIRST ROUND PLAYOFF LOSSES. NO WAY YOU CAN BE CONSIDERED GOAT WITH THAT SHIT.

People are just suckers for media hype.


Favre STILL holds yards record , and just lost td record same amount of rings.

Lol. Peyton manning best regular season Qb of all time. All time? No way. You gotta WIN.

I don't like Brady at all. But Brady > manning.

Montana > manning.

Gtfo. Take all those regular season records and have fun with em

[CelticBaller]

The people rating Montana and Brady above Manning are just dumb.


These are the same people that rate Bill Russell in the Top 5 or as the GOAT.


Peyton Manning is the best QB of all time. No one Quarterback has been able to accomplish what he has. Period.

how does you analogy make sense? Brady has thrown 50 tds in a season and has won MVP twice for putting the best passing numbers in both those years respectively

[Patrick Chewing]

Lol. Lol.


Peyton manning best regular season Qb ever.


1 - 2 in superbowls. Only one he won against Rex fuccin gross man. Lol.


8 FIRST ROUND PLAYOFF LOSSES. NO WAY YOU CAN BE CONSIDERED GOAT WITH THAT SHIT.

People are just suckers for media hype.


Favre STILL holds yards record , and just lost td record same amount of rings.

Lol. Peyton manning best regular season Qb of all time. All time? No way. You gotta WIN.

I don't like Brady at all. But Brady > manning.

Montana > manning.

Gtfo. Take all those regular season records and have fun with em

Because one man controls the fate of the entire team....


So Ben Roethlisberger is better than Manning then, right??

[Bless Mathews]

The people rating Montana and Brady above Manning are just dumb.


These are the same people that rate Bill Russell in the Top 5 or as the GOAT.


Peyton Manning is the best QB of all time. No one Quarterback has been able to accomplish what he has. Period.

Actually. I think your right.

HAS ANY QB LOST 8 FIRST ROUND PLAYOFF GAMES???

Yea. I think he's the only one that has accomplished that.

Idiot.