In the regular season, you're facing bad teams, mediocre teams, etc. In the regular season, a player like Nash or Rose can be considered the MVP.
In the all-star game, you're facing the absolute best players from the opposing conference.
The all-star game is the best of the best, and surrounding circumstances, such as the current state of a particular team, are irrelevant.
The all-star game is the most competitive and most star studded event the NBA has to offer.
Results 1 to 15 of 25
-
11-29-2015, 01:40 AM #1Free the banned users.
- Join Date
- Apr 2014
- Location
- Gainesville, FL.
- Posts
- 26,914
What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
-
11-29-2015, 01:41 AM #2Off the Meds.
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
- Posts
- 1,901
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
-
11-29-2015, 01:41 AM #3NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
- Join Date
- Apr 2011
- Posts
- 26,742
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Even by your standards this is a moronic thread.
-
11-29-2015, 01:43 AM #4NBA Legend
- Join Date
- Jan 2014
- Posts
- 17,125
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Actually this is a very useful "test case" for how logic can be manipulated.
Your points all seem valid in theory, and if you were explaining this to someone who didn't know anything about the NBA, it would probably make a lot of sense.
Obviously we all understand the context and that you are a shameless troll, and thus know it's a completely worthless point.
But it's interesting how convincing a point can be made to sound without all the proper context.
I'm gonna keep this analogy in my backpocket. Thanks stalker.
-
11-29-2015, 01:46 AM #5Free the banned users.
- Join Date
- Apr 2014
- Location
- Gainesville, FL.
- Posts
- 26,914
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
So since we all agree that the all-star game MVP is more important, simple because all the best players in the world come together in this remarkably star studded competitive event...
Kobe has the most all-star game MVP awards of all time.
Only proving again that he's the 2nd GOAT.
-
11-29-2015, 01:46 AM #6Banned
- Join Date
- Feb 2009
- Posts
- 14,477
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Kobe Bryant - 1 mvp
shaquille O'neal - 1 mvp
oscar Robertson - 1 mvp
hakeem Olajuwon - 1 mvp
Julius Erving - 1 mvp
Bob Cousy - 1 mvp
Kevin Garnett - 1 mvp
Barry Sanders - 1 mvp
John Elway - 1 mvp
Maurice richard - 1 mvp
Babe Ruth - 1 mvp
ken griffey jr - 1 mvp
Ty Cobb - 1 mvp
Ricky Henderson - 1 mvp
Jerry West - 0 mvps
Elgin Baylor - 0 mvps
John Havlicek - 0 mvps
George Mikan - 0 mvps
Derrick Jeter - 0 mvps
mark mcgwire - 0 mvps
derrick rose - 1 mvp
steve nash - 2 mvps
lebron james - 4 mvps
peyton manning - 5 mvps
just sayin
-
11-29-2015, 01:48 AM #7Free the banned users.
- Join Date
- Apr 2014
- Location
- Gainesville, FL.
- Posts
- 26,914
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Ether.
Originally Posted by kennethgriffin
-
11-29-2015, 01:49 AM #8Future NBA G.O.A.T
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Posts
- 12,431
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
where can i donate some brain cells
-
11-29-2015, 01:49 AM #9NBA Superstar
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
- Posts
- 13,351
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Which is kind of impressive, when you think about it. Originally Posted by Smoke117
-
11-29-2015, 01:52 AM #10Banned
- Join Date
- Mar 2015
- Posts
- 5,418
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
tim duncan 2 mvps
Michael Jordan 5 mvps
Kareem 6 mvps
lebron 4 mvps
kobe bryant 1 mvp
derrick rose 1 mvp
allen iverson 1 mvp
dirk 1 mvp
Just sayin'
-
11-29-2015, 01:53 AM #11well well well
- Join Date
- Jun 2010
- Posts
- 21,652
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
how they love to talk about shaq when it favors their agenda Originally Posted by kennethgriffin
bran fam
REST.
IN.
PISS.
-
11-29-2015, 01:53 AM #12Banned
- Join Date
- May 2014
- Posts
- 2,890
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
Originally Posted by GIF REACTION
-
11-29-2015, 01:54 AM #13Banned
- Join Date
- Feb 2009
- Posts
- 14,477
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
the allstar mvp list looks better than the regular season mvp list
Allstar MVP
2000[b] Shaquille O'Neal Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (6)
2000[b] Tim Duncan^ Forward/Center United States[c] San Antonio Spurs (2)
2001 Allen Iverson Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (5)
2002 Kobe Bryant^ Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (7)
2003 Kevin Garnett^ Forward United States Minnesota Timberwolves
2004 Shaquille O'Neal (2) Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (8)
2005 Allen Iverson (2) Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (6)
2006 LeBron James^ Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers
2007 Kobe Bryant^ (2) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (9)
2008 LeBron James^ (2) Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers (2)
2009[b] Kobe Bryant^ (3) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (10)
2009[b] Shaquille O'Neal (3) Center United States Phoenix Suns
2010 Dwyane Wade^ Guard United States Miami Heat
2011 Kobe Bryant^ (4) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (11)
2012 Kevin Durant^ Forward United States Oklahoma City Thunder (3)
2013 Chris Paul^ Guard United States Los Angeles Clippers (2)
2014 Kyrie Irving^ Guard United States[a] Cleveland Cavaliers (3)
2015 Russell Westbrook^ Guard United States Oklahoma City Thunder (4)
only one that seems out of place is kyrie
League MVP
1999–00 Shaquille O'Neal Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (7)
2000–01 Allen Iverson Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (6)
2001–02 Tim Duncan^ Forward/Center United States[c] San Antonio Spurs (2)
2002–03 Tim Duncan^ (2) Forward/Center United States[c] San Antonio Spurs (3)
2003–04 Kevin Garnett^ Forward United States Minnesota Timberwolves
2004–05 Steve Nash Guard Canada[d] Phoenix Suns (2)
2005–06 Steve Nash (2) Guard Canada[d] Phoenix Suns (3)
2006–07 Dirk Nowitzki^ Forward Germany Dallas Mavericks
2007–08 Kobe Bryant^ Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (8)
2008–09 LeBron James^ Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers
2009–10 LeBron James^ (2) Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers (2)
2010–11 Derrick Rose^ Guard United States Chicago Bulls (6)
2011–12 LeBron James^ (3) Forward United States Miami Heat
2012–13 LeBron James^ (4) Forward United States Miami Heat (2)
2013–14 Kevin Durant^ Forward United States Oklahoma City Thunder
2014–15 Stephen Curry^ Guard United States Golden State Warriors (2)
Iverson, Nash, Nash again, Rose all look out of place. and lebron has way too many while kobe/shaq dont have enough
-
11-29-2015, 02:01 AM #14Free the banned users.
- Join Date
- Apr 2014
- Location
- Gainesville, FL.
- Posts
- 26,914
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
[QUOTE=kennethgriffin]the allstar mvp list looks better than the regular season mvp list
Allstar MVP
2000[b] Shaquille O'Neal Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (6)
2000[b] Tim Duncan^ Forward/Center United States[c] San Antonio Spurs (2)
2001 Allen Iverson Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (5)
2002 Kobe Bryant^ Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (7)
2003 Kevin Garnett^ Forward United States Minnesota Timberwolves
2004 Shaquille O'Neal (2) Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (8)
2005 Allen Iverson (2) Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (6)
2006 LeBron James^ Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers
2007 Kobe Bryant^ (2) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (9)
2008 LeBron James^ (2) Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers (2)
2009[b] Kobe Bryant^ (3) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (10)
2009[b] Shaquille O'Neal (3) Center United States Phoenix Suns
2010 Dwyane Wade^ Guard United States Miami Heat
2011 Kobe Bryant^ (4) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (11)
2012 Kevin Durant^ Forward United States Oklahoma City Thunder (3)
2013 Chris Paul^ Guard United States Los Angeles Clippers (2)
2014 Kyrie Irving^ Guard United States[a] Cleveland Cavaliers (3)
2015 Russell Westbrook^ Guard United States Oklahoma City Thunder (4)
only one that seems out of place is kyrie
League MVP
[SIZE="1"]1999
-
11-29-2015, 02:03 AM #15NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
- Join Date
- Apr 2011
- Posts
- 26,742
Re: What's more important, a regular season MVP or an all-star game MVP?
[QUOTE=kennethgriffin]the allstar mvp list looks better than the regular season mvp list
Allstar MVP
2000[b] Shaquille O'Neal Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (6)
2000[b] Tim Duncan^ Forward/Center United States[c] San Antonio Spurs (2)
2001 Allen Iverson Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (5)
2002 Kobe Bryant^ Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (7)
2003 Kevin Garnett^ Forward United States Minnesota Timberwolves
2004 Shaquille O'Neal (2) Center United States Los Angeles Lakers (8)
2005 Allen Iverson (2) Guard United States Philadelphia 76ers (6)
2006 LeBron James^ Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers
2007 Kobe Bryant^ (2) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (9)
2008 LeBron James^ (2) Forward United States Cleveland Cavaliers (2)
2009[b] Kobe Bryant^ (3) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (10)
2009[b] Shaquille O'Neal (3) Center United States Phoenix Suns
2010 Dwyane Wade^ Guard United States Miami Heat
2011 Kobe Bryant^ (4) Guard United States Los Angeles Lakers (11)
2012 Kevin Durant^ Forward United States Oklahoma City Thunder (3)
2013 Chris Paul^ Guard United States Los Angeles Clippers (2)
2014 Kyrie Irving^ Guard United States[a] Cleveland Cavaliers (3)
2015 Russell Westbrook^ Guard United States Oklahoma City Thunder (4)
only one that seems out of place is kyrie
League MVP
[SIZE="1"]1999
Reply With Quote
