20 straight seasons or 13 seasons with multiple retirements?

[FultzNationRISE]

Which is more befitting of a sport's "GOAT?"

You tell me. I'm just asking a question.

And I'm not gonna say which players this is about just yet, I will reveal that later in the thread. For now I just want honest answers unencumbered by bias and agendas.

[theman93]

Hmm, I'm not sure. Let's ask Lebron.

[Shaquille O'Neal]

Hmm, I'm not sure. Let's ask Lebron.

6 in 13 or 4 rings with 3 asterisks in 20?

I'll take the dude with 6.

Anyone dumb enough to argue the 20 year career being better - take away everything else - if LeEPO could, would he trade 5500 regular season points for 2 more chips / 2 more FMVPs / 9 more scoring titles / 1 DPOY?
Answer: Of course he would. There's your answer without even bothering to get into all the LeFailures.