Ugly, Unaesthetic style players should never be considered for GOAT

[nineiron]

in any sport.

[Bronbron23]

in any sport.

I'm assuming you're talking about Bron? Sure alot of his scoring skill set is ugly but the other parts of his game are fine. Plus Kareem game wasn't pretty and he still has a good argument for goat

[RRR3]

Steaming

[bison]

Giannis is the worst. His style makes lebron look like Dr J.

[Bronbron23]

Giannis is the worst. His style makes lebron look like Dr J.

Not really. Both have a ugly scoring skillset

[BarberSchool]

Ugly yet dominant brutality should get respect. (shaq)

On the other hand:

Ugly finesse & ugly perimeter play, should get nothing but MF ridicule

[TheMan]

I'm assuming you're talking about Bron? Sure alot of his scoring skill set is ugly but the other parts of his game are fine. Plus Kareem game wasn't pretty and he still has a good argument for goat

I never heard Kareem's game being ugly, unless you consider the sky hook an ugly shot.

[nineiron]

I'm assuming you're talking about Bron? Sure alot of his scoring skill set is ugly but the other parts of his game are fine. Plus Kareem game wasn't pretty and he still has a good argument for goat

i'm talking about any player with an ugly game. not just bron.

other parts of his game? such as?

[Bronbron23]

I never heard Kareem's game being ugly, unless you consider the sky hook an ugly shot.

I don't think it's ugly but alot of people do. Even Kareem himself acknowledged that the reason most players of today don't learn the sky hook is because it's ugly. Not sexy is the words I think he used.

[Bronbron23]

i'm talking about any player with an ugly game. not just bron.

other parts of his game? such as?

He's not a ugly passer, rebounder or defender when he was in his prime. There's more to the game then scoring. Magic had a pretty ugly scoring game but overall his game was nice because of the other things he could do

[Shooter]

Not really. Both have a ugly scoring skillset

BronBron23 fuming

[Bronbron23]

BronBron23 fuming

Right I'm fuming because brons scoring skill set is relatively ugly

[nineiron]

He's not a ugly passer, rebounder or defender when he was in his prime. There's more to the game then scoring. Magic had a pretty ugly scoring game but overall his game was nice because of the other things he could do

how can you be an ugly rebounder or defender?

as for his passing, it's not pretty. he exaggerates his motion when he passes so it looks flashier, but it's not smooth.

the only time he's not ugly is when he dunks.

[ImKobe]

Are 3PT chuckers considered aesthetic?

[zeerghit]

I don't think it's ugly but alot of people do. Even Kareem himself acknowledged that the reason most players of today don't learn the sky hook is because it's ugly. Not sexy is the words I think he used.

any source?