Why not Duncan for GOAT?

[soots]

Its subjective and to me hes top 3 with Russel MJ.

Small market team Ring - check
3 Decades - check
4 different situations - check
solo ring - check
best team in pro-sports - check
beat and retired Lakers superteam with 2x top 10 GOAT - check
beat and retired Heat superteam - check

[bizil]

GOAT status factors:

Solo Accolades
Team Accolades
Numbers
Peak Value
Longevity being great
Impact on the league (redefining a position, causing rules changes, globalizing the game,etc.)

When u add all these factors up NO WAY is Duncan the GOAT. In my opinion, the top 4 are MJ, Kareem, Russ, and Magic. But the next six spots are very interchangeable in how u could rank it. So at best, I see Tim in the top 5 or 6.

[k0kakw0rld]

I have never seen a player as stiff as him becoming a superstar let alone win 5 rings and The guy is a 7 footer yet plays below the rim.

he also won in a small market. 5 rings is the best for small markets while you have boston, lakers winning 15+ then chicago 6.


And he won 5 in a more stacked league compared to the watered down 90s

People are scared to admit it but he is a lock for TOP 5

KAJ
MJ
BRON
RUSSELL (popular vote)
DUNCAN
---------------------
Wilt
Magic
Bird
Shaq
---------------------
Big Oscar
Olajuwon

[BarberSchool]

I have never seen a player as stiff as him becoming a superstar let alone win 5 rings and The guy is a 7 footer yet plays below the rim.

he also won in a small market. 5 rings is the best for small markets while you have boston, lakers winning 15+ then chicago 6.


And he won 5 in a more stacked league compared to the watered down 90s

Because he was never the consensus most dominant player on BOTH ends of the floor for his entire era.











You facetious troll.

[Kenomax]

Not enough from Duncan to be GOAT, but I have him at 7 so he's top 5 runner.

[Spurs5Rings2014]

Its subjective and to me hes top 3 with Russel MJ.

Small market team Ring - check
3 Decades - check
4 different situations - check
solo ring - check
best team in pro-sports - check
beat and retired Lakers superteam with 2x top 10 GOAT - check
beat and retired Heat superteam - check