2014 Edition of ISH's All-Time List: #13

[DaSeba5]

Michael Carter-Williams

Let's get this ***** on the list!

I was going to keep it up as a joke, but I took it off.

[Jlamb47]

KG

[ArbitraryWater]

Dirk

[Le Shaqtus]

Dirk.

[ArbitraryWater]

Dirk

Where is the gif where he sticks his tongue out? Was complimentary

[inclinerator]

matthew deladadova

[Sakkreth]

Julius Erving

[DMV2]

Barkley

[kshutts1]

Have yet to vote in these threads, but I can't let Dirk beat out KG...

KG.

[Sakkreth]

Have yet to vote in these threads, but I can't let Dirk beat out KG...

KG.

KG is not top 20.

[kshutts1]

KG is not top 20.

We each have our own criteria and lists, but I have KG ranked identically to Duncan.

"Flame" all you want, but I don't concern myself with team accomplishments when rating players, and taking championships out of the equation leads me to believe that KG and Duncan are on the same tier (I do tiers) and Dirk is... well, behind them.

[Milbuck]

Where is the gif where he sticks his tongue out? Was complimentary

Shit I forgot. Edited.

[navy]

I already voted for Doctor J, but why on Earth would Dirk be above Jerry West?

[kshutts1]

I already voted for Doctor J, but why on Earth would Dirk be above Jerry West?

I love Dirk, and think he's a fabulous player, but I have no clue why people rank him higher than Doc or West or KG.

He's more in the 3rd or 4th tier in my opinion, which is no slight to him... puts him around the 20-25 mark. Hardly anything to be dissatisfied about.

[DaSeba5]

What's up with all the Dirk votes lately? I'm not saying he doesn't deserve it or anything, but I'm curious on why some of you rank him so high.