Which Player Would You Rather Take?

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Player A:

18p/7r/7a with 4 Turnovers on 54% TS 102 ortg, 110 drtg

Player B:

23p/3r/4a with 3.5 Turnovers on 46% TS 90 ortg, 108 drtg


If you had to pick one?

[Inferno]

Player A

[Deuce Bigalow]

Player B

[Legends66NBA7]

[JimmyMcAdocious]

B. But if either are my #1's then my team might as well tank for the top pick.

[RoundMoundOfReb]

B. But if either are my #1's then my team might as well tank for the top pick.

Agreed. Wouldn't want either but gun to my head i'd take A.

[Young X]

Statistically I would take player A, Lebron but the circumstances around Bron's series is what made it worse than Kobe's.

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Statistically player A, Lebron was better but the circumstances around Bron's series is what made it worse than Kobe's.

Explain please. What circumstances?

[JellyBean]

Player A

[Mure]

Player A.

[Mr. Jabbar]

which ever can get it done without the need of 3 other hofers in their prime

[RoundMoundOfReb]

which ever can get it done without the need of 3 other hofers

Neither of them can.

Player A had 2 future HOF teammates on his team at the time

Player B had 3 future HOF teammates on his team at the time

[Milbuck]

They both sucked ass in different ways. Switch both of them and they both do substantially better. Lebron can defer to Shaq all he wants and be a playmaker rather than scorer, while Kobe can shoot all he wants against a much softer defense.

[outbreak]

Player A
But comparing stats like this is silly you need to factor in the team they are playing on and what role the team needs.

[Young X]

Explain please. What circumstances?

Circumstances wasn't the right word but after all that happened the in the previous 12-13 months, for Lebron to fold like that was more embarrassing to me. They both played terrible and ineffective basketball but Kobe just played horrible, Lebron completely choked.